Inheritance
discussion
What about Saphira and Firnen?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Katie
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Dec 19, 2011 09:50AM
Do you think that Firnen should have went with Saphira since they love each other?
reply
|
flag
He couldn't exactly abandon Arya. I like how it ended, but I would certainly like there more of story between Saphira & Firnen, Arya & Eragon, Murtagh & Nasuada. Maybe Christopher will write another series with a different main character but all of these ones can still be in it.
He said something about coming back to Alagaesia. Maybe he'll write another book about a new rider and how that changes everything?
Ashley wrote: "He said something about coming back to Alagaesia. Maybe he'll write another book about a new rider and how that changes everything?"If you look on his website, Ashley, he says that he's writing shorter but more sequels.... he says he's going to write them soon.YEAH!! sooo excited.... he says he's going to write at LEAST three more sequels... awesome!
I didn't like his reasons for leaving, how does he know that the place where they're going isn't as bad (or worse!) then the one they're leaving behind?
Sarah wrote: "I didn't like his reasons for leaving, how does he know that the place where they're going isn't as bad (or worse!) then the one they're leaving behind?"Yeah, that's what i thought too! Christopher said that a lot of answers will be in the sequels.
Yeah, I just thought it was idiotic on Eragon's part, taking his dragon and hundreds of eggs into a completely unknown part of the world, that could have creatures even more powerful than dragons!
Sarah wrote: "Yeah, I just thought it was idiotic on Eragon's part, taking his dragon and hundreds of eggs into a completely unknown part of the world, that could have creatures even more powerful than dragons!"I know, when it ended i was like, 'What?!?!?! that's sooo screwy!' idk... guess he'll write it in the later sequels.... wish they would just come out already!! HAHA!! LOL!
Paolini is no longer writing about Eragon!! does no one read the letter at the end??!! he did say that he didn't want to leave Alagaesia behind...
Yeah, but if you read his interview from his website... he said that he was going to write smaller, but more books to the series LATER
Firenen seemed a bit too... young, in my opinion, for Saphira. Maybe it's because he came so late in the story.
Michael wrote: "Firenen seemed a bit too... young, in my opinion, for Saphira. Maybe it's because he came so late in the story."I argree. She could be his grandmother. I even felt the same about Thorn.
Badgerlord wrote: "I argree. She could be his grandmother. I even felt the same about Thorn."It just feels even weirder when I put Thorn in to the mix now.
Katie wrote: "Ashley wrote: "He said something about coming back to Alagaesia. Maybe he'll write another book about a new rider and how that changes everything?"If you look on his website, Ashley, he says that..."
Yay!! I only glanced, I didn't have a chance to actually sit down and read what it said, so thanks for updating me!
Clara wrote: "it is!!!"IKR?!?! I love it, and even better, he sends emails to you if about new things coming up!! AH!!! soooo cool!! can't wait for the next things?
Badgerlord wrote: "Michael wrote: "Firenen seemed a bit too... young, in my opinion, for Saphira. Maybe it's because he came so late in the story."I argree. She could be his grandmother. I even felt the same abou..."
This. I couldn't believe she mated him. I was so mad D:
Ellie wrote: "Same. I was so annoyed ---- It should, should, should have been Thorn!"Well, I didn't really want it to be Thorn either, because of the age difference, but I think he was a much better choice than Firnen. And Gladear was too old when she tried to hit on him, lol xD
Maryam wrote: "Ellie wrote: "Same. I was so annoyed ---- It should, should, should have been Thorn!"Well, I didn't really want it to be Thorn either, because of the age difference, but I think he was a much bet..."
I agree, thorn had to much on his mind. Nobody, currently, is right for Saphira. It's just the truth!
Maryam wrote: "Ellie wrote: "Same. I was so annoyed ---- It should, should, should have been Thorn!"Well, I didn't really want it to be Thorn either, because of the age difference, but I think he was a much bet..."
HAHA!! XD
Maryam wrote: "Badgerlord wrote: "Michael wrote: "Firenen seemed a bit too... young, in my opinion, for Saphira. Maybe it's because he came so late in the story."I argree. She could be his grandmother. I even f..."
I hated this part, too! She sees him for all of two pages than jumps him. I was always rooting for Saphira and Thorn because they're the closest in age and it would've complicated the story for the better, I think.
Patti wrote: "Maryam wrote: "Badgerlord wrote: "Michael wrote: "Firenen seemed a bit too... young, in my opinion, for Saphira. Maybe it's because he came so late in the story."I argree. She could be his grandm..."
Yeah, I don't believe in love at first sight. I think that this was only done because of Eragon's feelings for Arya.
I really wish that Saphira was going to have an egg before they left. It would have made so much sense. Maybe Paolini thought that taking away the love interest and having his hero sail off into the sunset instead of tying a thousand loose ends back home was sophisticated or cool, but it really was annoying, frustrating, and just a terrible choice as a writer. These books wasted so much of my time- I wanted to see what happened, but then it was a dead end.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic

