Midnight discussion

I want to know how many people like this book.

not better then the others, no.

I like it. Granted, it's not on Firestar, but it's on new, young cats. w/ a new adventure staring them in the face!! ;D

Hate all of them with Bramble and Squirrel and Leaf's point of veiw >> I hate all of them

whatever...

eh just my opnion

:) well, everyone is granted they're own opinion!

^^

Me gustan ellos todos!

:D ditto!! i have almost ALL of them!! (except like, the feild guides...)

same here

this was the only one i ever read, so...
but i did like it.

i like it. the badger part startles me. knew it couldnt actually be @ midnight, so i thought it wouldve been a different animal.

I wanted to put this book down and not even read the "Moonrise" so I have to say no.

I didn't like this book. The traveling was a bit
draggy. I think the first series is better

I like it just as much as the others, I like the new characters and adventure

I personally love all the books equally.

So no I can't say that I love it more, but I love it.