Reader's Ink discussion
Story of Beautiful Girl
>
Linnie
date
newest »
newest »
I thought Linnie was a tad idealized--whether she had a disability or not, she could've been portrayed as more complex--or even flawed, as characters have flaws--than she was.
Her life in the state school was very tragic. However, the biggest tragedy--to me--was the loss of her baby girl. Instead, Simon focused on Linnie's pining for Buddy. What a missed opportunity on Simon's part! As a mommy, I cannot imagine the pain of giving up the baby you so wanted to keep. That would've been a fantastic opportunity for the reader to really connect wiht Linnie. I mean, obviously she's capable of love and attachment, because she loves Buddy so much, right? So why no longing for her baby?
Her life in the state school was very tragic. However, the biggest tragedy--to me--was the loss of her baby girl. Instead, Simon focused on Linnie's pining for Buddy. What a missed opportunity on Simon's part! As a mommy, I cannot imagine the pain of giving up the baby you so wanted to keep. That would've been a fantastic opportunity for the reader to really connect wiht Linnie. I mean, obviously she's capable of love and attachment, because she loves Buddy so much, right? So why no longing for her baby?



Her past? (such with family, mother, sister, etc..)
Her life in the State School? ( her friends, coping at the school, the dangers, etc...)
Her relationship with Buddy?
Her decisions as a mother?
Linnie chose to go to Martha's house because of the Lighthouse Man.
What is the symbolism of the Lighthouse Man?