Dawn
discussion
Who else likes the new WindClan?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
♥Booknerdswift♥
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jul 31, 2012 04:40PM
i for one, do not. i like it when thunderclan and windclan are friends, especially firestar and onestar's friendship.
reply
|
flag
Breanna wrote: "i for one, do not. i like it when thunderclan and windclan are friends, especially firestar and onestar's friendship."
Same here.
Same here.
Breanna wrote: "i for one, do not. i like it when thunderclan and windclan are friends, especially firestar and onestar's friendship."
Obviously, if they kept their friendship, the series would be too bland. I mean, the traditional hate relationship within ShadowClan and ThunderClan is too typical, but expected to occur throughout each series. Personally, I was a little surprised when Onestar turned his back on Firestar, but Onestar had matured. He became a leader, and you can't deny that that changed things. He thought it would be best to try and lose all friendly ties within other Clans, because he thought it would make them safer.
I kind of liked it. It also gave more depth to the amount of danger Leafpool had put her Clan in by mating with Crowfeather, and in the end, that just weakened their relationship more.
Obviously, if they kept their friendship, the series would be too bland. I mean, the traditional hate relationship within ShadowClan and ThunderClan is too typical, but expected to occur throughout each series. Personally, I was a little surprised when Onestar turned his back on Firestar, but Onestar had matured. He became a leader, and you can't deny that that changed things. He thought it would be best to try and lose all friendly ties within other Clans, because he thought it would make them safer.
I kind of liked it. It also gave more depth to the amount of danger Leafpool had put her Clan in by mating with Crowfeather, and in the end, that just weakened their relationship more.
I liked the new them too, they were too boring before
I hate how onestars and firestars relationship is ruined! AND I LOVED TALLSTAR WHY THE *********** DID HE HAVE TO DIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*Stomps off in an angry rage*
Jaidyn wrote: "It's kind of really old WindClan..."i dont get it, how is it old windclan?
Alana wrote: "I hate how onestars and firestars relationship is ruined! AND I LOVED TALLSTAR WHY THE *********** DID HE HAVE TO DIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!..."
...... It's called a novel. You know how awful books would be if no one died? If you like it that way, go read the Magic School Bus or something. No one dies in that!
But seriously, why are people so against cats dying? I mean, loads of my favorite characters have died, but I don't through a hissy fit like a 2 year old about it. I mean, if you write a book like that, it's going to be awful.
Besides the point, Breanna, what Jaidyn was trying to say (I think) was that WindClan used to be really strong and stuff, and very independent. I vaguely recall in the first-early second series many other Clans teased ThunderClan and WindClan about the fact that they were all buddy-buddy.
Not to mention WindClan had been driven out of their home early on, and they seemed really weak and frail. Onestar probably just wants to regain the respect his Clan had lost.
...... It's called a novel. You know how awful books would be if no one died? If you like it that way, go read the Magic School Bus or something. No one dies in that!
But seriously, why are people so against cats dying? I mean, loads of my favorite characters have died, but I don't through a hissy fit like a 2 year old about it. I mean, if you write a book like that, it's going to be awful.
Besides the point, Breanna, what Jaidyn was trying to say (I think) was that WindClan used to be really strong and stuff, and very independent. I vaguely recall in the first-early second series many other Clans teased ThunderClan and WindClan about the fact that they were all buddy-buddy.
Not to mention WindClan had been driven out of their home early on, and they seemed really weak and frail. Onestar probably just wants to regain the respect his Clan had lost.
I liked it when Onestar and Firestar were friends. I wonder why they are being hostile to ThunderClan.
Okay so I don't like onestar but still, windclan is my favorite.
Onestar used to be my favorite cat in WindClan.
Teddy wrote: "I liked it when Onestar and Firestar were friends. I wonder why they are being hostile to ThunderClan."
I just explained that in the post above....
I just explained that in the post above....
I don't like the new WindClan because Onestar isn't a cool leader.
Nope*spoiler* if you haven't read the last hope, onestar and firestar became friends again, kinda. well all the clans became friends.
i like tallstar better, but onestar improves
but onestar's still awesomego warriors! :3
