Until Tuesday discussion

I was excited about this book, but made the mistake of looking up Montalvan's life before reading it and came across some sources that claim most or all of his war stories are fabricated (including how he injured his leg).
I am now wondering if this will taint my reading of this book. I read A Million Little Pieces prior to the outrage of some of the events being glorified for the book. It didn't ruin my opinion about the book b/c I had already considered it a great read. I am wondering if I will enjoy this book knowing ahead of time that not all of it may be truthful.

What are others opinions? Does he have the right to fabricate a bit, or should it be considered fiction so that the reader isn't thinking it's all truthful? Opinions from those who have read the book as to whether I should read it appreciated, too!

After researching his case a little I don't believe he fabricated anything written in this book. He has told the events as he recalls them. Our memories are not perfect, so there is always the possibility of making small errors when relaying a story. However it all happened; it impacted Montalvan's life in ways we can only imagine. He is not just some guy off the street trying to write an awesome story. He was a Captain in the Army fighting to protect our freedom. It disgusts me to think that there are reporters out there trying to discredit this man who was willing to put his life on the line and represent our country in such a wonderful way. And he hasn't stopped. He is continuously speaking, raising awareness for individuals in the military who need help. He is a pretty stand up guy. They can say what they want, but I believe every word he says.

The first thing I see when I open my eyes is his snout plopped on the covers; the first thing I hear is the happy huff of his breathing and the sound of his tail whapping against my dresser.There is nothing more calming in the morning than petting a dog.

Tuesday is so very important in his relationship with Luis. The bond is unbreakable, the loyalty is heartwarming, and the importance of what they do for others is incredible. It is so refreshing to see a viewpoint from a soldiers point of view. Thank you Luis and Tuesday for sharing you story with us.

I believe his story to be true. I am sure there are people who are not going to be happy about what he says about the government or the Army...too bad. Sometimes the truth hurts.

Post traumatic stress disorder is a real disorder and if he says he has this then I believe he does. If he writes a book to show other sufferers of PTSD how this great organization can help them with their lives by providing one of these wonderful dogs then he is a hero once again by helping other people change their lives. I think he and Tuesday are very courageous!

Alison wrote: "One detail that would have made the book ring more true for me was about the dog's elimination. We read of a small apartment, owner sometimes in bed for days--how did the large dog cope?"

A problem I have is the fact that he lets his dog act in unacceptable ways while he has his working vest on. An example being allowing the dog to run around an eliminate while wearing the vest. Morris Frank never allowed Buddy to act like that while in the working gear, but when the working gear was off, Buddy was allowed to be a dog.

I reviewed the book, met the author and his dog, and was deployed myself. I feel a bit uncomfortable about this book, based on all that and want to note that some of the criticisms come from those he was deployed with. However, it will soon be a movie. . . . so there will be even more visibility.

Kristi wrote: "After researching his case a little I don't believe he fabricated anything written in this book. He has told the events as he recalls them. Our memories are not perfect, so there is always the poss..."

I agree Kristi. We all live in our own reality of situations. I eventually met Capt. Montlavan and Tuesday. What I was able to see matched what was in the book. I am giving copies of his children's book, Tuesday Tucks Me In to the local holiday collection for Christmas gifts.

It's 12/9/16...You all can put aside your differences, Louis Died today alone in a hotel room.
Tuesday is ALONE NOW and needs our support and prayer's.

Sailor wrote: "It's 12/9/16...You all can put aside your differences, Louis Died today alone in a hotel room.
Tuesday is ALONE NOW and needs our support and prayer's."

Yeah, I heard about that and I find it most interesting that he did not have Tuesday with him. I wonder why that is!!!

I wondered about that also. I will still keep both in my prayers.
I do not do all the social media sites. Any info would be appreciated.

I think he just didn't want Tuesday to be at his side when he commited suicide.
It's heartbreaking. I've read about a half of the book and made the mistake of googling the author - I wanted to see how he looks like. And I found out he commited suicide...