Status Updates From Montana 1948
Montana 1948 by
Status Updates Showing 1-30 of 7,445
Antonio Quiroga
is on page 43 of 186
I am so astounded by the fact that Uncle Frank turned out to be a molester who molested helpless native american girls or, as the book calls them, "indians". I am even more flabbergasted by the fact that the dad knew that his brother did it without any evidence that he was guilty. It leaves me with the question: what is the dad hiding from us, and what else does he know?
— 9 minutes ago
Add a comment
Michael Bao
is on page 43 of 186
I was surprised that Wesley didn't believe Marie's accusation against his brother, Frank. This made me realize that family relationships can influence a person's judgment. Wesley cannot listen to the accusation objectively because Frank is his own brother. I wonder if it's hard to accept the truth when it challenges your preferences about someone you know really well.
— 17 minutes ago
Add a comment
Talbot Sheldon
is on page 13 of 186
Right from the beginning Larry Watson really describes Montana and some important things about montana. Larry says "The ability to drive the county's rural roads, often drifted over in the winter or washed out in the summer was a much more neccesary skill than being good your fist or a gun." That scentence is important because the weather can be tricky in Montana with dry summer and snowing cold winters
— 31 minutes ago
Add a comment
Pablo Ramirez
is on page 39 of 194
I think things are going to get worse as more secrets about Frank come out. I feel like Wesley will have to make a difficult choice between protecting his brother and doing what's right. I also think Gail will push him to stand up for Marie, while David slowly starts realizing how messed up his family situation really is.
— 31 minutes ago
Add a comment
Yoonsol Yang
is on page 43 of 186
At first, I assumed Wesley was pretending to believe Marie's claims, but I was shocked when it was implied that he may have known about his brother's crimes. I questioned why he would keep this information to himself, especially as the sheriff. Thinking back to the prologue, I suspect Wesley might abandon the investigation to protect his brother, putting family loyalty above justice, leading up to the gun scene.
— 41 minutes ago
Add a comment
Ben Connick
is on page 47 of 186
Didn't see that coming i know there was something up with Frank because Marie didn't want anything to do with him but didn't think it was going to be that. I feel super bad for Wes because at the end of the page 43 when Gail askes him that question. He didn't answer it because he new that he was guilty the whole time. Im super curious because I want to know what will go down with Wes being the town sherif.
— 55 minutes ago
Add a comment
Joseph Clottey
is on page 43 of 186
David’s family seems respected in town, but I’m starting to wonder whether that respect comes from fear or actual admiration. Something about Uncle Frank’s visit to examine Marie feels uncomfortable. When she repeatedly shouts “no,” David’s father tries to distract him instead of checking what is happening. Why is everyone acting like this is normal? I’m starting to wonder what secrets this family is keeping.
— 1 hour, 23 min ago
Add a comment
Bode Hayes
is on page 15 of 186
Larry Watson hooked me right away with a tense, mysterious vibe. His narration is very straightforward and he uses foreshadowing and vivid 1940's Montana details to make you feel like you are standing right there. That simple language feels even heavier because it hides secrets. Early themes of family, loyalty, and justice already stand out, making me wonder how far some people in the book will go to protect family.
— 1 hour, 24 min ago
Add a comment
Coleman Martin
is finished
In Montana 1948 I noticed that when David was ease dropping on his parents he wanted to run away. I thought that was intresting because I would have wanted to hear more but maybe in that situation I would have been scared. I am now wondering what Davids dad is going to do because it is a hard situation he is the law and he have to enfoirce it but it is his brother so he has to use morales and ethics to decide.
— 1 hour, 25 min ago
Add a comment
Amir Hofer
is on page 45 of 194
i am starting to notice that family and secrets are important themes in this book. I think it is interesting how people can act differently depending on who they are around. The writing also makes the story feel realistic and keeps me interested. I want to keep reading to find out what happens next.
— 1 hour, 35 min ago
Add a comment
Constantino Laborin
is on page 45 of 186
In these pages of Montana 1948 David starts learning more about his family and the secrets they are hiding. His father starts acting more serious and his uncle Frank becomes a bigger problem. David notices that adults do not always tell the truth and that some secrets can change everything.
— 1 hour, 41 min ago
Add a comment
Kross Pelletier
is on page 30 of 182
In pages 30–43 of Montana 1948 by Larry Watson, the tension in the Hayden family continues to grow. Wesley is forced to deal with the serious accusations against Frank, while David begins to realize that his family is hiding something important. This shows how difficult it can be to choose between family and doing what is right. Do you think Wesley will put his family first or do what he believes is right?
— 1 hour, 44 min ago
Add a comment
Niklas Tahvanainen
is finished
So far I like how the kind of small town Montana is giving me like a feeling that everyone is connected and it gives more tension to the book. Still wondering what other secrets David is keeping about Frank and I am looking forwards to see how he is at the end of the book.
— 1 hour, 44 min ago
Add a comment
Read Mortimer
is on page 45 of 186
The book has taken a very unexpected turn. David's mother has clearly been greatly affected by this, as has David's father. They both know it's true that Frank is guilty; however, I do wonder whether they will actually do something about it. I have a good feeling David will. One big question is why the closest hospital is 40 miles away? That's not too convenient for a town, especially in 1948.
— 1 hour, 47 min ago
Add a comment
Ethan Dutton
is on page 40 of 194
Marie has finally confessed why she does not want to see Frank. She says that Frank is sexually abusing and raping indigenous girls in the town. I don't think the narrators dad will get his brother in trouble I think he will cover for him.
— 1 hour, 49 min ago
Add a comment
Dylan Gonzales
is on page 43 of 194
I think the story is starting to become more serious because Marie is still sick and Wesley is wondering what Frank has been up to. It affected me that David thought that someone in his family was up to something bad, and I think that something worse is going to happen. I hope that Marie gets better and David finds out what Frank has been up to because I think he is up to something thats not good.
— 1 hour, 53 min ago
Add a comment
Dylan Chen
is on page 43 of 186
As troubling rumors begin to surface around Uncle Frank, the tension inside the Hayden household shifts from mild worry to a serious moral crisis. Watching these dark family secrets unfold through young David’s eyes captures the painful loss of childhood innocence. The question is, When protecting your family means ignoring a terrible truth, where do you draw the line and step in to do what is morally right?
— 1 hour, 53 min ago
Add a comment
Angel Genaro
is on page 29 of 194
I am so shocked with how the first chapter ended. I did not expect the story to have a very shocking ending. On page 34 " Is that your brother has molested Indian girls". After reading this was very jaw dropping since I didn't expect to read that. Why do you think you Frank rapped native american girls?
— 1 hour, 53 min ago
Add a comment
Will Clark
is on page 43 of 186
After reading the first 43 pages of Montana 1948, I find the end of the chapter most intriguing. I think Uncle Frank should be in jail immediately if what he did is true. I feel that he should not be able to rape his patients and get away with it. And the fact that he even goes to schools just makes me very uneasy. Do you think this will change the plot of the story?
— 1 hour, 54 min ago
Add a comment
Griffin Watts
is on page 43 of 186
I was very disappointed to hear about uncle and his behavior. Marie reaction was completely justifiable. Rightfully so david's reaction should be anger. Earlier in the book we learned that Wesley doesn't were the badge because of the weight it carries. Both physically and mentally. I believe that mental weight came from knowing what Frank does and not acting upon it. I am interested to see the response from Wesley.
— 1 hour, 57 min ago
Add a comment
Henry Price
is on page 30 of 186
The story took an extremely violent turn, becoming a twisted murder mystery. It explores how difficult it can be to stand up for what you believe is morally right when family is involved. Wesley is in a tough position, choosing between protecting his brother, Frank, and doing his job as a defender of the law. The question that is raised is: Will Wesley do the right thing, or will David have to step in?
— 2 hours, 20 min ago
1 comment
Landon Miller
is on page 45 of 186
I was in disbelief when I realized the real truth of Frank on page 34. I see why Marie did not want them to be one on one in a room. I found it understanding that Wesely was in disbelief when figuring this out because he was once a police chief who he looked up to and feels that he cannot live up to his fathers name which is why he hides his badge. There has been so much that has escalated so quickly.
— 3 hours, 24 min ago
Add a comment
Leon Chen
is on page 43 of 186
The "twist" as i called it wasn't as dramatic as I thought because there wasn't much buildup that early in the book. On page 43, Gail says "Just one thing, Wes. You never said you didn't believe it. Why is that? Why?" I like that sentence because in the pages before, Wes is shown to be more against the thought that his brother was sexually assaulting people. This quote however, shows that he was really in denial.
— 5 hours, 56 min ago
Add a comment
Omar Kuri
is on page 43 of 186
It is shocking how Uncle Frank abuses women while hiding behind his respected position as a doctor. Even more disturbing is how David's dad knew about it but stayed silent because Frank was his brother. It makes me question how far family loyalty can go when someone does something wrong. By protecting Frank, David's dad failed the women who had been and would be abused by him. Something that should not happen.
— 7 hours, 10 min ago
Add a comment
Shuchen Wang
is on page 15 of 186
"I" lived in Bentrock, Montana - a simple and serious little town. The protagonist yearned for freedom and exploration of the outside world, but this was contrary to the expectations of his father who is the sheriff of the town. His father wanted to maintain the traditional way of life, but his mother wanted him to become a lawyer and move to a more livable place. I am thus caught in a state of conflict.
— 7 hours, 45 min ago
Add a comment
Chauncey Li
is on page 43 of 186
I’m shocked that the father is a corrupt sheriff who let a serious crime go. I suspect he allows other crimes, too, which might explain why he doesn’t carry a gun to work. What silent but serious crimes has he ignored? I was also surprised that he’s racist and horrible, though perhaps it stems from his poor upbringing by the grandfather. The plot Watson revealed will lead to conflict within the family and with Marie.
— 8 hours, 0 min ago
Add a comment
Ian Lee
is on page 41 of 182
I really enjoy Larry Watson’s writing because he conveys emotion, imagery, and realism through his words. I can picture exactly how each scene is set up, and I can even imagine distinct voices for the characters. He also does a great job of slowly building suspense, which I thought only happened in horror movies. I hope he keeps that same thrill throughout the rest of the book!
— 8 hours, 38 min ago
Add a comment




