Status Updates From Who Killed Albus Dumbledore...

OMG! I forgot how obsessed the fandom was with the Lupin isn't Lupin stuff. And how it transformed from "Lupin is actually James Potter" to Lupin is actually a polyjuiced Wormtail. LOL. This was such a wild time.

Oh Daniela! Her theories on what could potentially be Horcruxes were honestly so good! And she got the Harry one right on! I’m bummed she was wrong about Erised, well researched theory! And she actually mentions and dismisses the diadem in her theory

There’s a note before Sally’s essay saying even before this collection was published her theory was disproven. However, I loved it. This was my ffavorite part of the fandom, analyzing speech patterns and parallels for any hint of a clue. Plus the Switching Spell Hype. Peak HP fandom gold here.

Wendy had some interesting insights on the Black family. Unfortunately a good bit of her theory ended up being untrue; but it was a solid prediction and some of her thoughts and exploration still holds up.

This came out between books 6 and 7, but some of their questions were answered in book 6. Like, for supposed “experts” they missed giant plot points of the book they were analyzing. But I’m interested to see what others have to say. I’ve read enough of John Granger’s BS