Status Updates From Montana 1948
Montana 1948 by
Status Updates Showing 1-30 of 7,636
Jihwan Park
is on page 30 of 186
Watson explores the distinction between one's public reputation and private character through the Hayden family. Although its members are mostly well regarded by the community, their social status does not necessarily reflect their personalities, as demonstrated by Julian being demanding and authoritative, despite his high social status. Through this contrast, Watson challenges the credibility of social reputation.
— 6 hours, 50 min ago
Add a comment
Antonio Quiroga
is on page 76 of 186
I don't think Uncle Frank will stop his grotesque actions just because his brother told him to. Since he's a repeat offender—kind of like how drug addiction works—he won't feel satisfied where he is and will want to do this more frequently. I don't see a reason why he would stop, since his own brother, who is also the sheriff, doesn't want to arrest him, which already puts him above the law.
— 8 hours, 55 min ago
Add a comment
Harrison Lamont
is on page 75 of 194
Things I found interesting on pages 65 77 of Montana 1948 is how David is starting to understand how much his family is hiding from him. It is interesting because Frank is someone David has looked up to, but now he is beginning to see a completely different side of him. This shows how people are not always who they seem to be, even when they are family. I'm excited to see what Wesley will do when it comes down to him
— 8 hours, 55 min ago
Add a comment
Ivy von Seldeneck
is on page 26 of 186
As I continue reading I am starting to see the flaws in the Hayden Family. I see how Uncle Frank can be a lot worse than this outstanding chad war hero. I also see the racism towards the native americans in this time period, even with the sheriff, David's dad, hating native americans. I see how Larry Watson depicts the way power can inflict negative actions in people, like David's grandfather.
— 8 hours, 57 min ago
Add a comment
Victor Sweeny
is on page 43 of 186
A constant theme that keeps coming up in the novel is competition. Throughout the story, Wesley and Frank are constantly in competition with each other. Most of this bad blood was provoked by their father. Their competition during their lives allowed them to know one another better than anyone else. The competition was in gaining their father's attention and appreciation and in who could do better in life.
— 8 hours, 57 min ago
Add a comment
Kross Pelletier
is on page 77 of 182
I think it is interesting how the adults in the story handle difficult situations. It makes me wonder whether family loyalty is more important to them than doing what is right. How far would someone go to protect their family?
— 8 hours, 57 min ago
Add a comment
Santiago Braun
is on page 75 of 194
It's clear that David doesn't like Uncle Frank anymore. He can't stand the thought of his uncle being a sexual abuser. However, he also feels attracted to Aunt Gloria, and he says that he is jealous of Uncle Frank for having her. For these reasons he hates Uncle Frank, and would've killed him if he would've had bullets in his gun. David might be developing a strong personality of his own like his grandpa.
— 8 hours, 58 min ago
Add a comment
Leon Chen
is on page 63 of 186
David wants his father to tell his grandfather what he has learned about Frank. Surprisingly, his grandfather jokes about Frank had sex with an indian is the past, and how there could even be some of Frank's children on the reservation. I think this development is here to make the story more interesting now that we the readers and David now know that we can't just go to Grandfather to handle what Frank is doing.
— 8 hours, 58 min ago
Add a comment
Landon Miller
is on page 93 of 186
I was amazed to learn about uncle Franks father. The story of him at the bar was very eye opening to me. When one guy made just a tiny joke Wesely lashed out pulling out a nice and shiny revolver putting that man at threat. The grandfather comes off to me as a very cocky man. It seems to me that his ego could very easily be broken. That specific part out of all the parts of the story definitely popped out to me.
— 9 hours, 6 min ago
Add a comment
Ivy von Seldeneck
is on page 11 of 186
Through eleven pages, I am really interested in the line of the Hayden Family in the town, and I am very curious to see where this goes. David's dad and his grandfather clearly have a lot of power in their town, I wonder if this is a good or bad thing continuing through the book. There are some hints that David's grandfather is not as good as he seems. I am also wondering more about David's dads childhood.
— 9 hours, 6 min ago
Add a comment
Niklas Tahvanainen
is finished
Klotey was really right, the book really turned into a murder mystery when Marie died. I wonder if she really died due to a sickness or that's just what people think. I think frank killed him, because the word what he did to Native americans might've got out and he might've gotten scared.
— 9 hours, 7 min ago
Add a comment
JJ Cheung
is on page 93 of 186
What stood out to me most here is how David’s role completely changes. Earlier I noticed he was mostly just a kid watching from the sidelines, even turning on the radio hoping Marie would feel better. By the end of this part, realizing what Uncle Frank’s afternoon visit actually meant forces David to speak up, and it’s wild seeing him suddenly have to be a witness against his own uncle.
— 9 hours, 7 min ago
Add a comment
Ben Connick
is on page 86 of 186
A lot has happened in the last 20 or so pages. I learned more about the grandfather and how easy it is to make him mad. David also got a gun and killed a bird and when he killed it he said he was more calm witch I can relate too. He's going thru a lot of stress and a little thing like that can clear his mind. Marie died also Frank said it was the sickness but i'm not buying that. I think something happened to her.
— 9 hours, 12 min ago
Add a comment
Benjamin Ficek
is on page 27 of 186
Uncle Frank is hiding something. Wes Hayden and his dad, Grandpa Hayden don't like the idea of fences as they think it closes off the land and they dont want that but then why does Uncle Frank want a fence for privacy? The author is manipulating the story by adding these small changes from the characters personality, that become more important ideas on purpose that make the reader think. Frank might not be innocent.
— 9 hours, 13 min ago
Add a comment
Cayden LeRoy
is on page 43 of 186
The novel takes a disturbing turn. Marie was nervous of Frank because he was a known molester! Although the narator's father heard what was happening, the constant voice of her saying "No", didn't faze him. Frank's presperation on his shirt makes the reader think differently that he didn't treat her but did something else. The narator now feels anxious around Frank. Will Frank do something to him? Can he be trusted?
— 9 hours, 13 min ago
Add a comment
Griffin Watts
is on page 93 of 186
I was not suppressed by the remorse that everyone showed to Marie's death. She was such a key figure in the story and the uncle frank situation. The knowing of uncle Franks action still is hanging over everyone's heads especially Wesley. I think after reading I see a shift in his perspective on how he will hopefully prosecute Frank. I wonder if David will pursue the Frank situation till he gets justice?
— 9 hours, 14 min ago
Add a comment
Maxwell Gu
is on page 43 of 186
Watson manipulates the story by having an older David tell it, letting him hint at disaster and build suspense. He makes Frank a hero everyone loves, so the truth shocks the reader and the characters. Watson uses a kind of karma in the parents’ deaths, where Wes, who kept the family’s secret, dies slowly of cancer, while Gail, who stood for the truth, gets a merciful death. Why doesn’t Watson let the law punish them?
— 9 hours, 14 min ago
Add a comment
Maxwell Gu
is on page 43 of 186
Watson manipulates the story by having an older David tell it, letting him hint at disaster and build suspense. He makes Frank a hero everyone loves, so the truth shocks the reader and the characters. Watson uses a kind of karma in the parents’ deaths, where Wes, who kept the family’s secret, dies slowly of cancer, while Gail, who stood for the truth, gets a merciful death. Why doesn’t Watson let the law punish them?
— 9 hours, 15 min ago
Add a comment
Maxwell Gu
is on page 43 of 186
Watson manipulates the story by having an older David tell it, letting him hint at disaster and build suspense. He makes Frank a hero everyone loves, so the truth shocks the reader and the characters. Watson uses a kind of karma in the parents’ deaths, where Wes, who kept the family’s secret, dies slowly of cancer, while Gail, who stood for the truth, gets a merciful death. Why doesn’t Watson let the law punish them?
— 9 hours, 15 min ago
Add a comment
Thomas Tanglertsumphun
is on page 43 of 186
Larry Watson purposely made David a child. Having an innocent view and strong curiosity, David is involved in overhearing his parents argument. Listening, he is shocked to find out that his uncle, whom he has seen as a decorated war hero like in the movies, was raping his patients. Emphasizing the author's intent to show David's disbelief, he also hears his mom tell his dad words he has never heard her say.
— 9 hours, 18 min ago
Add a comment
Read Mortimer
is on page 93 of 186
I was stunned by the realization of Marie’s death. This has greatly impacted David’s family and will probably cause a multitude of problems for the near future. However, David's father may have more investigating to do after David revealed to his family that Uncle Frank snuck into their house uninvited. This begs the question: did Uncle Frank kill Marie?
— 9 hours, 26 min ago
Add a comment
Oliver Ellis
is on page 43 of 186
The author purposely made Uncle Frank the favorite child for a reason. Davies’ dad always listened to his father and never said no, while Frank didn't always do what he was told. Because of this, when Grandfather Hayden asked Davies’ dad to become sheriff, he didn't even consider saying no. Frank, on the other hand, would have refused because he wanted to be a hero and gain fame.
— 9 hours, 27 min ago
Add a comment
Jay Kang
is on page 43 of 186
Finishing up part 1 of the book, Watson's intent in telling the story through a 12 year old's eyes is crucial. Watson wants the readers to feel David's shock and confusion with him. Young David isn't told the truth, and has to piece it together himself from overheard conversations. I also think old David explaining some aspects of the story show how much he rethought and the summer and how long it stayed in his mind.
— 9 hours, 35 min ago
Add a comment
Liam Tith
is on page 32 of 186
I have stumbled on multiple examples of things than can be referred to the prologue. An example that we used in class was how David's father had a slow and painful death that could have been a sign of karma. This peels layers of the onion, uncovering the unknown from the memories in the prologue. Uncovering the truth about Uncle Frank seems to me more suspicions will start to rapidly unfold. Will the people find out?
— 9 hours, 35 min ago
Add a comment
Jaxon McNamara
is on page 93 of 186
Things take a wild turn in this part of the story, shortly after they return from the grandparents' house, Marie dies. One thing that stood out to me was how emotional David's father was about Marie's passing. This leads me to believe he actually cared about her. I don't believe she died because of illness, and I wonder just how she died. Was it Uncle Frank who did something?
— 9 hours, 45 min ago
Add a comment
Mike Liu
is on page 48 of 186
At the end of the chapter, I think the author was trying to show that not everyone was perfect and that there are always downsides to somebody. In the town, David's family is very respected, but there are also secrets that their family keeps. I also think that the author is trying to set up a conflict between if family loyalty is more important or doing the right thing is more important.
— 9 hours, 45 min ago
Add a comment
Angel Genaro
is on page 77 of 194
I not totally shocked finding about Marie Little Soldiers death. I believe that the author was giving us hints on how Marie was going to died. We also notice that David wanted to kill Uncle Frank for what he did to Native American Girls. On page 77 " The next day Monday August 13, 1948 Marie Little Soldier was dead". How do you guys think that Marie Little Soldier Died?
— 9 hours, 46 min ago
Add a comment
Michael Bao
is on page 74 of 186
I feel confused because the adults in the book seem to keep things secret, thinking they can protect their family and keep them from getting involved. However, I wonder if keeping Uncle Frank's crimes secret is making the situation worse. It's ironic that adults whisper and keep David from getting involved, even though he knows exactly what's going on.
— 9 hours, 52 min ago
Add a comment




