Status Updates From Thrawn Janet

While we don't have explicit statements from Stevenson about his reasons for using Gaelic, his careful approach to writing and his deep interest in Scottish culture suggest that these choices were intentional and purposeful, rather than casual.

Realism in storytelling: Stevenson was known for his meticulous observations of culture and his desire to create realistic portrayals. Using Gaelic in stories set in Scotland or featuring Scottish characters would have enhanced the realism of his narratives3.

Cultural exploration: Stevenson's use of Gaelic allowed him to delve deeper into Scottish folklore and traditions. This is evident in his poem "Heather Ale," which retells a Scottish legend about the Picts and their secret brewing recipe2.

Audience engagement: Stevenson showed a keen interest in writing for specific audiences. His short story "The Bottle Imp" was originally published in Samoan, making it the first piece of literature published in that language3. This suggests that Stevenson was intentional about using local languages to connect with his readers.

Linguistic preservation: By using Gaelic in his works, Stevenson contributed to the preservation and promotion of the language, which was already declining in use during his time.

Cultural authenticity: Stevenson incorporated Gaelic to add authenticity to his Scottish-themed stories. For instance, in "Will o' the Mill," he includes a story originally told in Gaelic by Donald MacFarlane, demonstrating his respect for the oral traditions of the Scottish Highlands1.

Robert Louis Stevenson's use of Gaelic in some of his stories appears to have been a deliberate choice with specific purposes, rather than a casual decision. There are several reasons for this:

I’m struggling with the language!
Although a short read, I barely got through the first two pages, and hardly understood their contents.

Jesus, I understand nothing. I looked at the rating 2.89 and was shocked. Now I see why.

Janet slays. Idk its written in old Scottish like slang but the bits I could read i enjoyed so 2 stars feels appropriate. Just read it in a Scottish accent and I think you'll understand the slang a lil better