Grace Peck > Recent Status Updates

Me every time I open up this book “so where we, ah yes, the pit of despair”

People on TikTok are so annoying with how they talk about this book but like I do have agree re reading this as an adult I hate everyone here lmao just absolutely nightmare blunt rotation of human beings

Christina ima need you to stop pining for a man here good lord “you are woman with a brain, stop whining and find something to do!!!”

Audio book re read, I remember loving this book

One thing Anne Mallory is going to do, and that’s have a book loaded with sexual tension from page one! I see the puritans in some reviews don’t like that a romance novel is horny, the horror!!

“How had I, and so many others, been so vulnerable to being manipulated by someone like Jodi” gee I don’t know Shari, maybe because your family is a part of a religion that thinks a random man who married teenagers “found” magic plates from Jesus or whatever the fuck Mormans believe??? A church that teaches its followers about how the devil is lurking everywhere???

I don’t have kids yet, but the idea of subjecting my hypothetical children to random judgements and comments from strangers who don’t actually know them, or worse, pedos who follow these channels, makes my skin crawl.

People who watch and genuinely enjoy family channel vloggers are so fucking weird

“In my church, we’re encouraged to document our lives meticulously” oh like how yall did with the mountain meadows massacre??

*laughs nervously* is Shari….is she still a Mormon??? Willingly? After all her mom did??

Why le fuq are we calling catherine Carey catherine Howard, this is so weird

Something gay is going on here, I just can’t prove it yet

Very surprised that Philippa Gregory has not written a book from Margaret Douglas’s point of view like why was your last book some nonsense about Jane Rochford being a spy or whatever when you could do someone like Margaret Douglas?

Okay but how Nelly was villainized in the film and by stupid people on TikTok makes me so mad, she’s definitely not perfect but she’s also one of only adults in this book to be somewhat nice and encouraging to child Heathcliff - also she’s an adult servant, not a paid ladies companion??

“Nellys the villain” “no heathcliff is” no ur both wrong the real villain in this novel is Joesph!!

Okay interesting that early Jean Plaidy wrote in the style of a 70s bodice ripper, I didn’t know she was cool like that lol! Also pretty sure the term “ball” for a large court dance wasn’t used in England until like the 1600s so the usage feels annoying here.

Absolutely forgot how when we first meet child heathcliff he is described as an “it”

Why did we need to have multiple characters named Cathy in this lmao I have a character chart open to remember who is who

Been meaning to re read this for a long time and seeing the film (lmao) finally motivated me, and getting into, emerald, why the fuck did you not include ghosts??????

Read this in high school and remember thinking it was weird how weir wrote Eleanor as this like sexpot

Kind of surprised their aren’t more books and movies about Isabella’s early life and romance with Fernando, it’s a crazy story and pretty romantic (ruined by knowing he goes on to have mistresses after their marriage) but very exciting

fish is always the culprit in these food poisoning deaths

I think one my issues with some fantasy, or specificity this author, as a primarily historical fiction reader is that I’m not given enough details on the culture and the customs of these worlds to make them feel real. Any civilization with a government and a ruling class, from the courts of Europe to the Kuge in Japan have extensive cultural rules and practices, and when you write a fantasy world that doesn’t-

weird to me that the diviners are allowed to have sex with visitors. This might be my historical fiction brain ruining this, I think of them as nuns or vestal virgins, who famously could face dire consequences for having sex, but this is a fantasy novel so yes it’s different- but if the point is that the abbess is controlling them, would it not make sense for the diviners to have not be allowed that freedom?

I like this so far, actually, but the characterization of 6/Sybil is weird to me. The reader is told that she was the best diviner, the abbesses favorite, truly believed in all the stuff, which to me would imply a more “goody two shoes/teachers per” type of character, but we don’t really see her acting like that throughout this first chunk of the book here.

I am very over historical authors preaching and lecturing readers on what are very obvious injustices happening in the moment. It’s crazy to me how high of reviews this book has. “Remember that the next time you panic and call a man to do a woman’s job” ya I’m not really fan of pushing this idea that men can’t be capable of medical care during childbirth idk!

“Jane attended Anne after a miscarriage when no one else was allowed to” number 1, source! Number 2, that doesn’t necessarily mean they liked each other. Kinswomen generally attended to each other during shit like that out of family obligations, doesn’t necessarily mean they liked each other.

Probably going to dnf because this author very clearly has a historical agenda to push. Thomas Cromwell was the force behind Anne Boleyn’s death, not Henry (tho to be fair he did sign off on it). Like this authors forward has zero sources cited for her pretty bold claims she’s making about Henry VIII’s motives. I’m not a Henry defender of course, dude was wack, but I like nuance in real people ur writing

Adding William to the list of characters I want to fight irl

Want to see why this book had Emily Gilmore so excited!