David > Recent Status Updates

Showing 1-30 of 1,076
David
David is on page 171 of 308 of Starling House
— Nov 17, 2026 04:28PM 1 comment
Starling House

David
David is on page 113 of 268 of Marxism and the Human Individual
Schaff very openly uses the same language of "humanization" that Kolakowski would use in Main Currents. I wonder if Kolakowski avoided a chapter or section on Schaff out of respect or to avoid a polemic between the two. It seems an odd exception considering he included obscure Polish theorists in Volume 2.
— Nov 13, 2026 11:20AM Add a comment
Marxism and the Human Individual

David
David is starting Marxism and the Human Individual
Fromm's "humanism" in his preface is ridiculously vague to the point of meaninglessness.
— Nov 12, 2026 11:51AM Add a comment
Marxism and the Human Individual

David
David is on page 83 of 148 of A Philosophy of Man: [essays]
Decided to read Schaff before Kolakowski's early work to get a sense of his intellectual genealogy. You see where his frustration came from. Schaff criticizes the Stalin era for criticizing without engaging with the arguments of opponents, but I'm not sure he engages with Sartre here at all aside from three or four quote before moving on to a theory of socialist humanism.
— Nov 10, 2026 11:36AM Add a comment
A Philosophy of Man: [essays]

David
David is on page 1215 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
The 2005 epilogue is laughably incoherent. Kolakowski does an "end of history" victory lap talking about how China is a great evil and anti-free trade and anti-war protestors are obscurantists opposed to progress while also acknowledging (but not conceding) that there is "great danger" to the rapid advance of technology that modern capitalism has proved unable to cope with socially.
— Nov 09, 2026 11:02AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1206 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
The analysis of the New Left probably coincides with that of doctrinaire PCF intellectuals, just gives the impression of an old professor scared of the youth. The analysis of Mao's China ideologically is pure polemical nonsense, and he gets various points completely wrong. On these two phenomena he was writing far too early for an accurate analysis.
— Nov 09, 2026 08:49AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1143 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
"...the student New Left especially admired negro leaders in the United States who advocated violence and black racialism." (1179)

Jesus, way to go mask off buddy.
— Nov 09, 2026 08:34AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1143 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
Quick off the cuff and irrelevant dismissal of Heidegger's association with Nazism! One of the most egregious examples of nonsense in all three volumes! Genuinely caught me off guard!
— Nov 09, 2026 08:05AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1137 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
Kolakowski almost takes Bloch's overcoming of death as a genuine immortality, which is a silly misreading, but reels it back to the Feuerbachian influence, which then means he made that critique for no reason, but to just get a shot in at Bloch. Just being petty here.
— Nov 09, 2026 08:01AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1112 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
The wholesale dismissal of all of Marcuse's critiques of modern capitalism, in forming desires and technological, is very disheartening. By volume 3, he is not even engaging with the ideas he critiques except on a very basic philosophical level. The idea of Marcuse as the ultimate totalitarian, even further than Soviet Marxism (both dubious charges), would be funny were he not completely serious.
— Nov 09, 2026 07:35AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1112 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
Kolakowski is right to treat Marcuse's Freudianism as downright silly, vague and contrary to much of Freudian theory itself. Ironically he treats Fromm much more respectably despite the vague and silly nature of his Freudianism! Another example of Kolakowski picking and choosing his tone based on his personal perception of a theorist as a political threat.
— Nov 09, 2026 07:25AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1108 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
Kolakowski's critique of Marcuse's Hegelianism in defense of positivism is silly. Obviously Hegelianism had authoritarian aspects, but to pretend positivism was the absolute bastion of democratic thought (I am not denying its liberal wing) when it produced intellectual reactionaries like Taine and Social Darwinism is simply spiting Marcuse instead of reasoned analysis.
— Nov 09, 2026 07:21AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1086 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
The critique of the Frankfurt School, Adorno in particular, is extremely dense and fascinating, provides good insight into Adorno's work and the non-Marcusian wing. Yet again, however, Kolakowski's analysis is hampered by the ultimate conclusion that this particular branch of thought is obscurantist and full of truisms and thus is to be summarily discarded with no further thought to it.
— Nov 06, 2026 11:46AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1045 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
The section on Korsch is enlightening, but further proves Kolakowski's subordination of his political views to his scholarship. Were Korsch's views the same but in favor of the USSR, he would he condemned as an absurd obscurantist. Because he is an anti-Sovietist, he is treated gingerly and with respect.
— Nov 06, 2026 08:49AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1031 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
The ultimate condemnation of Lukacs as a Stalinist puppet is silly, although the criticism of his contradictory attitudes towards literature and ideology are sound. The idea of Lukacs as an anti-rationalist concerned merely with political primacy is simple polemic, without merit of any kind.
— Nov 06, 2026 08:10AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1015 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
Kolakowski's out of hand dismissal of The Destruction of Reason is ridiculous. He cannot deny the charges that Lukacs brought forth on idealist and vitalist philosophy and their influence on Fascism, so he must dismiss them as ridiculous and move on. Lukacs is not even adopting a doctrinaire or extreme Marxist position here.
— Nov 06, 2026 07:48AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 1008 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
Kolakowski's inability to grasp Lukacs' understanding of truth is hampered in that Tailism and the Dialectic was unavailable to him. For Lukacs' social dialectic and natural dialectic are separate; natural/scientific truth is different in its manner than social/political truth found in the class struggle. He is no "species relativist."
— Nov 06, 2026 07:28AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 989 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
It occurs to me that the attack on dialectical logic does not confront crit. of formal logic raised by Marxists; his crit. of Marxist unfamiliarity with modern philosophy of logic is sound, but acts as though philosophy of logic is historically a non-problem or Marxists are silly for approaching it despite its very long history. Kolakowski charges of truisms hold some water, but only in that it applies to all logic.
— Nov 05, 2026 02:00PM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 979 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
Unsurprisingly, and like many others, Kolakowski detected a contradiction between Gramsci's "philosophy of praxis" and philosophical materialism, but his understanding of materialism in that section is deeply simplified and reductive. He cannot properly the contradiction that exists other than asserting Gramsci's primacy of historicist human praxis makes it so. I am not convinced by the four pages devoted thereto.
— Nov 05, 2026 01:51PM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 891 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
"The whole difference comes down to thie: that Trotsky believed himself to 'represent the historical interests of the proletariat,' while Stalin believed that he, Stalin, did so." (946)
— Nov 05, 2026 12:47PM 3 comments
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 891 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
Zhdanov did great damage to Soviet Marxist philosophy in his static and vulgar division of "idealism" and materialism, in which Augustine and Bauer or Spinoza and Holbach's philosophies would be considered equivalent based on their underlying ontology, without a real grasp of their historical development.
— Nov 05, 2026 10:55AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 881 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
Historiography regarding the Terror and Stalin era in general, Arendtian in nature, doesn't hold up to modern academic historiographical scrutiny.
— Nov 05, 2026 10:42AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 819 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
He again allows his anti-Stalinism to take precedence over academic rigor asserting no difference between the Deborinites and the "New Philosophy" led by Mitin et al. Both Sheehan's scholarship and Chinese debates of the 1930s provide ample evidence of genuine ideological differences, not just some manifestation of further party control over philosophy.
— Nov 05, 2026 08:46AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 819 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
He lets his anti-communism take the lead once again; collectivization is such an evil that Soviet agriculture is said to have not recovered even into the 1970s, a pure fiction. His analysis of the Trotsky-Stalin split is salient in that it was personal animosity over actual theoretical difference; his analysis of the Bukharin-Probranzhensky debate is excellent. Sultan-Galiev deserved a longer analysis.
— Nov 05, 2026 08:00AM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

David
David is on page 632 of 1284 of Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown
Not sure how anyone who read Plekhanov could conclude Lenin's philisophical writing is cruder than his; Lenin at least engaged with the philosophical currents of his day as well as read Hegel historically rather than Plekhanov's brief overviews and simplifications.
— Nov 03, 2026 01:33PM Add a comment
Main Currents Of Marxism: The Founders, The Golden Age, The Breakdown

« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 … 35 36
Follow David's updates via RSS