Shawn’s Reviews > The Hobbit, or There and Back Again > Status Update

It's actually really solid. I personally didn't like it because it was way to long. The dwarves are a lot more rash then the movie. Who would wear the ring? I get that it gives the illusion of power to its wearer as well as being corruptive, but there is no reason to wear the ring if all it does is remove your presence. Gollum got done so unbelievably dirty in the movies compared to the book. He's actually scary now.