Ash Barron’s Reviews > They Drown Our Daughters > Status Update
Ash Barron
is on page 218 of 374
Am I the only one catching inconsistencies in the story? I mean I know we're all unreliable narrators but in chapter 12 Judith says she met her grandmother once the summer before she died- said she didnt talk much and just seemed sad. But in chapter 18 Diana is six months pregnant with Judith when Beth dies. She couldn't have met her grandmother. So im a bit confused???
— Jul 16, 2025 06:17PM
2 likes · Like flag
Comments Showing 1-2 of 2 (2 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Ash
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Jul 17, 2025 06:55AM
Actually now that I think about it this is Diana's first pregnancy which means it's not even Judith, its her older brother. So how could Judith possibly have met Beth??? An editor somewhere missed this.
reply
|
flag
But despite the inconsistencies I am actually loving this story! The plot is compelling and the conflict each generation between mother/daughter is so interesting
