kate’s Reviews > Superman: Earth One, Volume 1 > Status Update

im kinda torn how to rate this… i liked some of the quotes a lot! (even if they’re a little bit on the nose right) but not necessarily the storyline and how reluctant he was to step into his power. i prefer superman who doesn’t hesitate even for a second yk..?
it just read like a fanfic, in a way. au slightly ooc fanfic.

like 3.5 i guess. but will rate up.

“any final words to the billions who will die for the crime of having sheltered you?”

LIKE WHY U KILLING THEM BRO IT MAKES NO SENSE ???

lois is brilliant AGAIN tho <3 went into the red sun beam to save superman who she’s never seen before. like that’s my girl. save his ass girl. and stand tall for the truth

gosh i love her sm

like why are they also destroying earth? just kill clark, if you must? this isn’t about world domination.

but also— who came to them? why did that person want krypton gone?

im js so confused rn

ion get it… krypton is destroyed ? why do they need to haunt clark as well ???? like what’s the point of killing a child that nobody know escaped? their motivation doesn’t make sense to me??

no idea what page im on lol but idk… he’s too human and too flawed for my liking here. reads more like a fic so i dont understand why its a comic they planned ppl to pay for ?

gonna start later today!