Mary Van Winkle’s Reviews > The Overnight Guest > Status Update
Mary Van Winkle
is on page 80 of 316
My theories at this point:
-the shooter was Cutter & Cutter is Deb's son. Not Ethan since there were 3 shots ie one shot was Ethan
-Cutter is also the abductor. He's kidnapped Becky for years
- the woman in the snow is Becky or her unnamed daughter
But what happened to Josie & Ethan unless Josie is the woman in which case, where's Becky???
— Aug 21, 2025 07:19PM
-the shooter was Cutter & Cutter is Deb's son. Not Ethan since there were 3 shots ie one shot was Ethan
-Cutter is also the abductor. He's kidnapped Becky for years
- the woman in the snow is Becky or her unnamed daughter
But what happened to Josie & Ethan unless Josie is the woman in which case, where's Becky???
Like flag
Mary’s Previous Updates
Mary Van Winkle
is on page 239 of 316
Well I'm glad it wasn't everyone's obvious suspect b/c I didn't think that person was bad...but the real person? Mehhhh but I could be wrong
— Aug 23, 2025 12:52AM
Mary Van Winkle
is on page 50 of 316
Each chapter is a different narrative and it's pretty chaotic. I have 2 theories about who the abductor/kidnapped woman are
— Aug 20, 2025 07:11PM
