Nat Schaefer’s Reviews > Love and Loyalty > Status Update

Nat Schaefer
Nat Schaefer is 31% done
The cheesiest of all of them we have read. I think it may be the modernized abridged re-writing. The original books before they watered the stories down are so much better. (The 6 year old kid agrees). Will try finding copies of the original story collection to see if Felicity is less cheesy in the original style.
Aug 21, 2025 11:30PM
Love and Loyalty (American Girl Beforever Classic)

flag

Nat’s Previous Updates

Comments Showing 1-2 of 2 (2 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca Wolf Definitely try to find the pre-Beforever versions when each character has 6 smaller books vs 2 larger ones. If you can find the Pleasant Company editions, even better. I wish we still had ours, I'd send them your way, but I don't have them anymore. What was I thinking??? 😦


message 2: by Nat (new) - rated it 3 stars

Nat Schaefer @Rebecca I agree, the originals are 600x better than the BeForever versions! We have a bunch of them for other characters but not for Felicity yet. In the abridged version the mom is so saccharine and unrealistic. More fairytale character than mother figure.


back to top