Yuchen’s Reviews > Fundamentals of Software Architecture: A Modern Engineering Approach > Status Update
Yuchen
is finished
The first part of the book was hard to follow. It is because the the authors spent a lot of time to explain what's a design and architecture, and the reader can be easily lost in the terminology introduced by the book, name a few examples
1. architectural quanta
2. "fitness function"
I found the book scratching the surface on a lot of aspects, and giving very basic example (ordering system, which is too shallow)
— Oct 11, 2025 04:15PM
1. architectural quanta
2. "fitness function"
I found the book scratching the surface on a lot of aspects, and giving very basic example (ordering system, which is too shallow)
Like flag
Yuchen’s Previous Updates
Yuchen
is finished
Chapter 25 is the most interesting and I enjoyed it a lot.
At the end of the book, the author emphasized that all software architecture is a trade-off, also any architecture decision are not binary and fall into a spectrum of trade-offs.
Overall the last few chapters are also barely readable.
— Oct 19, 2025 09:21PM
At the end of the book, the author emphasized that all software architecture is a trade-off, also any architecture decision are not binary and fall into a spectrum of trade-offs.
Overall the last few chapters are also barely readable.
Yuchen
is on page 481 of 543
The last part of the book is barely readable. The problem is that the author has placed the software architect outside of the developer team, and then spent Chapter 21, 22, 23, 24 to describe how they can work together. From my work expereice, these engineers are from the same team and they usually work together.
I found the these chapter hard to follow.
— Oct 19, 2025 09:03PM
I found the these chapter hard to follow.
Yuchen
is on page 387 of 543
Part 2 is not very informative, except chapter 15.
Chapter 9 barely scratched the surface of the distributed system. Recently I've read Database Internals's Chapter 8, which done a much better job to describe all problems in less words.
Then the authors started to list all possible architectures. A lot of very shallow discussions, and I only learned a few interesting bit in Chapter 15.
— Oct 18, 2025 10:37PM
Chapter 9 barely scratched the surface of the distributed system. Recently I've read Database Internals's Chapter 8, which done a much better job to describe all problems in less words.
Then the authors started to list all possible architectures. A lot of very shallow discussions, and I only learned a few interesting bit in Chapter 15.
Yuchen
is on page 129 of 543
The first part of the book was hard to follow. It is because the the authors spent a lot of time to explain what's a design and architecture, and the reader can be easily lost in the terminology introduced by the book, name a few examples
1. architectural quanta
2. "fitness function"
I found the book scratching the surface on a lot of aspects, and giving very basic example (ordering system, which is too shallow)
— Oct 11, 2025 04:22PM
1. architectural quanta
2. "fitness function"
I found the book scratching the surface on a lot of aspects, and giving very basic example (ordering system, which is too shallow)
