Melvin’s Reviews > Desert Creatures > Status Update
Melvin
is on page 23 of 352
Is this a joke? Am I being pranked?
This does not qualify as a book. It would barely qualify as a bullet-point outline. Neither the content nor the craft is developed enough to qualify as even middle grade. This wouldn't be accepted for a 5th grade fiction competition. I am honestly surprised that something like this is capable of being published.
— Oct 18, 2025 04:50PM
This does not qualify as a book. It would barely qualify as a bullet-point outline. Neither the content nor the craft is developed enough to qualify as even middle grade. This wouldn't be accepted for a 5th grade fiction competition. I am honestly surprised that something like this is capable of being published.
Like flag
