Mac Navins’s Reviews > Montana 1948 > Status Update

It was interesting that to finish Franks story of sin, the author had him kill himself instead of facing punishment. This was not much of a surprise considering his reputation. I think this was added in because he knew that his life was over either way and he wanted to go out on his own terms. He decided to end his life early and keep his reputation in the afterlife. This added a sad touch to the end of the book.

It was interesting that Julian sent his men to take care of the Frank situation. This just continues to add to Julian's power and how he gets people to do whatever he wants. I believe that this is setting up for the shotgun scene, with Gail shooting them. I don't think Gail will kill anyone but may show that she is not defenceless by firing into the ceiling or away from the attackers. This is leading to the climax.

It was interesting how after the whole investigation of Frank, Wes still tried to keep it on the low. I think this is because he thinks he will gain more respect from his father. It was also interesting that Frank killed Marie because he thought it would keep her quiet. He instead sealed his fate because Len and David saw it. I believe this the author showing that David supported Marie by speaking up like she did.

It was interesting how the author had the part about killing the magpie. I think it is supposed to show how David is being changed, and to show his respect for the rest of the world. The magpie could symbolize his high esteem of his family, and especially of Uncle Frank, being shot down and covered in a thin layer of veiled hurt. He also found satisfaction in killing it, which shows how he has changed from the start.

It was interesting that the author had Grandpa's house be so large, but look simplistic. I found this to be an underlying symbol of power, as is already associated with him. This large but "simplistic" house is yet another reason Gail has to dislike the Haydens. Her continued dislike is setting up to look like she will be one side of a important argument about Frank with her husband or his family on the other side.

It was interesting how the author had David's dad dislike Indians when he seems good in other aspect.s I think this is because once he hears about what Marie said Uncle Frank does to Sioux girls it gives him more reason to not believe what she says. This means that even though he is the one investigating his brother, which already would add bias, he also doesn't like Indians, which makes it harder for him to believe.

It was interesting how the author continued to make David's father look meek and obedient. When Uncle Frank finished examining Marie he asked for a beer, and David's father ran to get one. This shows how much he looks up to his brother and is always trying to please him or his father in any way possible. This mentality could mean if something came up he would side with his brother because he wants to be appreciated.

It was interesting how the three generations varied, with the boys father wanting to be a lawyer, the boy being wild and the grandfather needing power. This adds separation between the generations because of different interests. There is also the setting, a small town with nothing to speak of. I think the author sets it as this so that it seems as though nothing will happen, but I believe that something will happen.