Olivia McCloskey’s Reviews > Good Girl, Bad Blood > Status Update
Olivia McCloskey
is 43% done
The high school-aged protagonist doesn’t understand how credit cards work yet is conducting a full-fledged missing person investigation. Even more bafflingly, all of the adults in the book are supportive of this and sitting down for recorded, police-level interrogations with the protagonist. Just when I thought this couldn’t get even more outrageous…
— Nov 19, 2025 02:21PM
Like flag
Olivia’s Previous Updates
Olivia McCloskey
is 66% done
The frustration is inevitable at this point, particularly when the high school-aged protagonist tries to tell police how to do their job after traipsing all around a crime scene. How have none of the adults put a stop to this "investigation?"
— Nov 19, 2025 03:38PM
Olivia McCloskey
is 24% done
And the realism element of the series has taken a nosedive off a cliff. A family is trusting a *high school student* to conduct a missing person investigation, and my ability to suspend my disbelief has left the building. I’m not feeling optimistic about the rest of this one…
— Nov 19, 2025 01:43PM
