Max Rose’s Reviews > Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix > Status Update
Max Rose
is on page 350 of 896
The Hog’s Head chapter… Harry really needs to stop being so sensitive about his classmates wanting more details about Voldemort coming back. Harry, my guy, no one saw him but you. And everyone in the whole world thought he was dead for 13 years. You HAVE to say more than “I saw him! He killed Cedric! I don’t wanna talk about it!”
— Dec 20, 2025 10:55AM
1 like · Like flag
Max’s Previous Updates
Max Rose
is on page 330 of 896
Leave it to Harry to get pissed at his best friends when they’re complimenting him for being good at defense against the dark arts and telling him he could teach them. “You guys don’t get it! I almost died and just got lucky. You’re so naive” Ok chill Harry, you’re being a jerk.
— Dec 10, 2025 01:33PM
Max Rose
is on page 279 of 896
I forgot how much of the early-pre Hogwarts stuff is in the movies and it’s nearly impossible now for me to use my own imagination for those scenes. There’s much more stuff at Hogwarts that gets jettisoned in the movies so those chapters are more fun to read. Not loving how Hermione is written because she seems to be an exposition tool. Hopefully that changes. And Book Ron is so superior to Movie Ron.
— Dec 05, 2025 01:24PM
Max Rose
is on page 179 of 896
Just finished the Hearing and The Woes of Mrs. Weasley. Solid chapters. This book has the longest preamble to Hogwarts of all of the books I think. I’m ready to board the train.
— Dec 02, 2025 09:41AM
Max Rose
is on page 137 of 896
Sometimes it’s hard to tell when a new magical “thing” has been introduced (like the Quibbler in this instance) because I have all the books and the movies jumbled together in my head. Anyways, I’m struck this re-read on how justifiably miserable Sirius is being cooped up in his old family home. I feel for him.
— Nov 30, 2025 02:34PM
Max Rose
is on page 79 of 896
Harry just started being insufferable, here we go.
— Nov 28, 2025 09:11PM
