Emma's In Stock’s Reviews > Three Tigers, One Mountain: A Journey Through the Bitter History and Current Conflicts of China, Korea, and Japan > Status Update

“It hadn’t really occurred to me to ask about the relationship between Taiwan and the third of my tigers, South Korea…”
…this book literally has South Korea in the title. What do you mean you didn’t even think about it? Maybe he was researching this stuff outside of planning for this book, but I’m sorry that’s absurd

Ok so Taiwan is where we actually see him talking about two countries in relation to one another that don’t include Japan.

2. I do like how he’s showing the nuance between the three Asian countries’ people and their feelings towards one another, but he himself comes off as biased

1. He’s splitting hairs here, to me. “He actually did apologize!” No he didn’t; “We do recognize that acts of cruelty and violence were committed by members of the Japanese military…” it’s too vague, like “oh we’re sorry these things happened” not “we’re sorry we did these things”
idk tho I don’t like the author’s handling this at all

(2) One that’s not an apology, and two that’s history for South Korea. I’m not saying the Japanese now should continue to have to pay for what the Japanese of then did, but at the same time we’re not gonna try to take away things that symbolize history

(1) When we were talking about the negotiations between South Korea and Japan, I thought that they were pretty ok. But one of Japan’s apologies, though compensating victims/victims’ families w/ however many millions of dollars, included South Korea’s end of the “bargain” being that they take down the memorial for comfort women.

Like I’m sorry but he does know that - I have to imagine - South Koreans and Chinese likely want the Japanese to apologize for NOT JUST THE COMFORT WOMEN, riiiiiiight?

Look I know we’re not talking about the comfort women anymore, but since we’re going through the atrocities that happened at Nanjing rn, him previously saying “Foreigners should have no say in telling the South Koreans to forgive the Japanese, but they could” *him as a foreigner btw* is just leaving a worse and worse taste in my mouth.