Moone’s Reviews > A Lady for a Duke > Status Update
Moone
is 60% done
As a romantic fantasy book this crushes. It's obviously unrealistic, from Viola's appearance, the levity her situation is treated with, etc.
I feel such creative liberties are perfectly fine. It is a historically themed sweet and romantic fantasy book.
I will admit, it is long. People are not wrong when they say it's a little too long...
— Jan 31, 2026 01:21PM
I feel such creative liberties are perfectly fine. It is a historically themed sweet and romantic fantasy book.
I will admit, it is long. People are not wrong when they say it's a little too long...
Like flag
Moone’s Previous Updates
Moone
is 81% done
Sex scene was nice. I was disappointed that Viola topped, but that's okay.
Mira's gay subplot has me interested I guess.
I'm wondering what's up with Amberglass. Is he gonna be like a foil or antagonist?
Gracewood and Viola should just marry already, jfc. It's already been shown in this world that she's totally unclockable, what could possibly go wrong?
— Feb 04, 2026 03:55AM
Mira's gay subplot has me interested I guess.
I'm wondering what's up with Amberglass. Is he gonna be like a foil or antagonist?
Gracewood and Viola should just marry already, jfc. It's already been shown in this world that she's totally unclockable, what could possibly go wrong?
Moone
is 42% done
Omg I love it. I like really super love it, in an embarrassing manner. I don't have an eye for literary quality yet, so I don't know how embarrassing a sentence this is, but: this is the most enjoyable book I've read.
The realization and following chapters absolutely gutted me while I was reading them. And the realization was so well set up, escalating and getting the reader's hopes up, just to drop you HARD
— Jan 29, 2026 04:30AM
The realization and following chapters absolutely gutted me while I was reading them. And the realization was so well set up, escalating and getting the reader's hopes up, just to drop you HARD
Moone
is 30% done
This is a slow burn and a half! If it continues on like this for the rest of the book it'll feel almost meandering.
I'm actually a huge fan of it, though. Looking at the rest of Hall's bibliography I really didn't think that'd be the case.
I just love the chemistry here, and the anticipation—oh Lord.
— Jan 27, 2026 12:54AM
I'm actually a huge fan of it, though. Looking at the rest of Hall's bibliography I really didn't think that'd be the case.
I just love the chemistry here, and the anticipation—oh Lord.
Moone
is 12% done
Woah, I think I love it? The mix of regret, yearning, and fear really form a solid mood. And I love Viola and Gracewood's dynamic and conversations so far. I think if it builds up right, the reveal's gonna be fucking magical (or at least impactful).
— Jan 25, 2026 05:06AM

