Gabrielle’s Reviews > Red City > Status Update
Gabrielle
is 8% done
Still debating if I want to continue this, the author has quite a bit of works that date pre-AI. Maybe it was a fluke?
— Feb 13, 2026 09:20AM
1 like · Like flag
Gabrielle’s Previous Updates
Gabrielle
is 8% done
I don't say this lightly, but, as someone who works in the AI tech industry much of this text screams of generative AI use. Not sure I'll be continuing.
— Feb 09, 2026 07:53AM
Comments Showing 1-6 of 6 (6 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Oldman_JE
(last edited Feb 13, 2026 11:50AM)
(new)
-
added it
Feb 13, 2026 11:46AM
Want to put some quotes out there that you found to be Ai-ish? I can throw them to the AI-Book-Hater's-Club and let them weigh in.
reply
|
flag
Oldman_JE wrote: "Want to put some quotes out there that you found to be Ai-ish? " Late reply but, yes sure! It could be just me spending so many hours a week processing LLM data but this reads so much like a GPT response:
"Alchemy is more than just the transformation of something into something else. It is not about changing lead into gold, or stone into water, or any element into another element. No, alchemy is about that eternal ache in us for perfection. It is our regret over all the things we never achieved, all the dreams we never got to fulfill. It is the questions that haunt us in the late hours of the night. Who are you, and who are you becoming? What world have you entered into, and what world shall you leave behind? What will you do, so that you matter? What mark will you leave, so that your existence was not in vain?"
Also note-- this is from the very few pages, no spoilers 😀
I haven't noticed anything in this book that stood out as a significant departure from her older works. The above quote of the fake book quote could arguably have been AI-generated and then human edited, but I find it too cohesive to be able to argue AI usage.Some of the other passages and descriptions of the book could border in that territory as well, but again in comparison to her older books, the writing and word usages are consistent enough that I wouldn't be able to say with confidence AI was snuck in to this book.
J.F. Penn however, is one author with a long established history that does use AI in her writing (and said as much in her blog), and it does show more clearly in Spear of Destiny, both through the cover and one of the early book lines:
The wind carried whispers of centuries past, of power and intrigue that once pulsed through the heart of an empire that commanded most of Europe.
I haven't seen anything in Red City that had the same sort of standout moment, but I'd be curious if you find anything else. Too much exposure to LLM text does corrupt the brain... it sucks.
Kari wrote: "Too much exposure to LLM text does corrupt the brain..."Completely agree. If its cohesive with her older works, that makes me feel better. Working 80 hours a week elbows deep in LLM data does skew the mind a bit. lol.
Thanks for the comment, that makes me feel better to continue reading 😀
Gabrielle wrote: "Working 80 hours a week elbows deep in LLM ..."Well that explains it, that's enough to drive anyone mad. Most of my exposure has been AI-generated books... a lot of them, so everything post-2023 starts me on alert.
I hope this one turns out to be an enjoyable read!

