Tin’s Reviews > Songs of Willow Frost > Status Update
Tin
is on page 256 of 338
Kinda drags a bit here with all of Liu Song’s backstory. I think what lost me here was that it’s all about reputation, appearances, and being Chinese which is less affecting to me as it’s a bit simplistic and shallow. Also the antagonists being vile is a bit boring.
But like Charlotte and her suicide was one of the moments that work because of her relationship with William.
— Feb 13, 2026 05:36PM
But like Charlotte and her suicide was one of the moments that work because of her relationship with William.
Like flag
Tin’s Previous Updates
Tin
is on page 148 of 338
It’s well written but it’s kinda trauma porn for Liu Song so it feels a bit over the top—very dramatized. But otherwise it’s fine. More setting u the story and whatnot
— Feb 12, 2026 06:12PM
Tin
is on page 104 of 338
A stellar opening in terms of writing. Charlotte is too sweet and nice it’s unrealistic that she’s so perfect but—oh no—she’s blind! It is very engineered to appeal to human tenderness which can feel a bit cheap.
And the depression era descriptions were good for creating the desperate setting for them to rough it out through, but otherwise took space from character moments I think.
— Feb 11, 2026 06:37PM
And the depression era descriptions were good for creating the desperate setting for them to rough it out through, but otherwise took space from character moments I think.
