Ashley Tenochitlan’s Reviews > The Oath We Give > Status Update
Ashley Tenochitlan
is 98% done
Ok so book 1 - 3.5 stars, book 2 - 5 stars!, book 3-4 - 4.5 stars.
This book was 2.5 stars 😒, only giving them that because they did wrap everything up but wtf happened 😭 what a waste. I can’t even explain it but Coraline and Silas relationship made absolutely no sense to me; very insta-love, no depth. Also, the underlying story had so much potential but ugh it just went down the drain. Sigh.
— Feb 17, 2026 02:52PM
This book was 2.5 stars 😒, only giving them that because they did wrap everything up but wtf happened 😭 what a waste. I can’t even explain it but Coraline and Silas relationship made absolutely no sense to me; very insta-love, no depth. Also, the underlying story had so much potential but ugh it just went down the drain. Sigh.
Like flag
Ashley’s Previous Updates
Ashley Tenochitlan
is 81% done
… so i actually don’t like Coraline or Silas…I feel betrayed for Rosie. I can’t believe this whole thing is ending like this…
— Feb 17, 2026 11:37AM