Ali’s Reviews > Then She Was Gone > Status Update

ALTERNATE THEORY noelle was wearing a rain coat when she found ellie on the street, on a sunny day. Floyd said that, who I presumed to be Ellie, ran away from him. Quite possibly, Noelle was going to run away that day and brought Ellie as a perfect replacement so she could escape easier.

OK NEW THEORY so yeah i was pretty fucking close with the last post but not quite. new theory is that noelle was dating floyd (since she’s not sjs mom) and couldn’t get pregnant so she brought in ellie as some messed up consolation prize or something. or to trap him. still fucked up but becoming more understandable in a way

THEORIES AHEAD Perhaps I’m being misdirected, but it seems fairly obvious that Ellie is Poppy’s mom, that Floyd is the dad. What’s less obvious is how he got her. My leading two theories is that (a) Noelle is SJ’s mom and Floyd’s ex, or (b) that she gave Ellie to him in exchange for money given she always talked about how poor she was.