Maddy’s Reviews > Challenger: A True Story of Heroism and Disaster on the Edge of Space > Status Update
Maddy
is on page 321 of 563
My jaw is perpetually clenched in the lead-up to launch. I know what's going to happen. The Thiokol engineers know what can happen. But, alas, "go fever" is festering. I do appreciate how much storytelling this book does, but I miss the level of technical detail I remember McDonald's book having. So far I feel like Adam's Chernobyl book was significantly better - but maybe that's because I'm not a nuclear engineer.
— Apr 27, 2026 12:12AM
Like flag
Maddy’s Previous Updates
Maddy
is on page 391 of 563
So harrowing and so sad. I can't imagine seeing this televised when it happened. So gut-wrenching. It's also quite clear which astronaut families decline to share their perspectives, which is both understandable but also makes me sad that their full stories are not told. I don't blame them for hiding from the press, but it makes it seem as if their crew member didn't have loved ones as well. Or maybe I'm crazy.
— Apr 28, 2026 12:18AM
Maddy
is on page 244 of 563
Introduced to Christa and shown the process of how she applied and eventually "won" her seat. Walking through an abort to orbit and, damn, I've got chills. Hindsight makes this closer to a suspenseful horror book, I swear.
— Apr 25, 2026 12:14AM
Maddy
is on page 216 of 563
Things are building towards the mission, we're getting a deeper background on the crew. Challenger was deeply shameful for NASA so it's hard to come by a comprehensive story - I'd only ever read one from the Thiokol side - so this is a great history deep dive.
— Apr 24, 2026 12:38AM
Maddy
is on page 174 of 563
No one ever wants to listen to the engineers. It's interesting hearing more of the Marshall side - the McDonald book was mostly Thiokol. It's very spooky reading all of this... like watching a car crash and you can't do anything to stop it.
— Apr 23, 2026 12:15AM
Maddy
is on page 144 of 563
I forgot how much I love space and NASA and the Shuttle (especially Discovery). I think not ending up at JPL, or even just NASA, led to me developing a protective indifference of sorts. Not sure I ever properly mourned that. Also, life is stressful and hard and I often find it hard to indulge in "dreamer interests" like this. Now's my chance for redemption.
— Apr 21, 2026 10:57PM
Maddy
is on page 78 of 563
The early achievements of spaceflight are bittersweet. They're quite exciting and incredible feats of science and engineering. They cut out women and non-Whites, using them as pawns to gain public favor when convenient and then denying them access to "the club". It's disgusting to read what some of these big names said about these applicants from marginalized communities. I'm glad Lovell has always been my favorite.
— Apr 20, 2026 11:23PM
Maddy
is on page 34 of 563
I forgot how captivating space history books are. Finally getting to this book... Only been about a year since meeting Adam Higginbotham at the Cosmos Club, so that's not too long of a wait. The story of Apollo 1 always gives me chills. Also, Higginbotham does such an incredible job compiling sources into a compelling, human story. I will always wish I could have experienced the dawn of the space age as a young boy.
— Apr 19, 2026 11:03PM

