maryam > Status Update
maryam
added a status update
unpopular opinion time!
- drop your unpopular bookish opinions in the comments !
— May 29, 2026 04:29AM
- drop your unpopular bookish opinions in the comments !
15 likes · Like flag
Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
maryam
(new)
May 29, 2026 04:29AM
unpopular opinion (?): but I dnf a book if the mmc's entire personality and pov is about the female lead. like does this man not have his own goals and ambitions? his own problems and emotions? hobbies he enjoys? other friends and family. it just pisses me off because how did the fmc fall in love with him in the first place if he has no personality? especially in a fantasy like you're literally in a battle why are you thinking about how pretty she is? it just feels so fake to me. and this obsession is always one sided. why isn't she as in love with him as he is with her? we yearn for mmcs with personalities.
reply
|
flag
my unpopular opinion might be uh really unpopular dont hate me guys but lauren roberts had a lot of potential to be a good writer and powerless couldve been a really good book if it wasn't plagiarized. she wrote a plagiarized book and thats her fault bc you should never do that but imo like i blame her for plagiarizing but part of me understands that at 18 your cognitive ability is not fully developed and if you're self publishing you probably just wrote a book for fun. HOWEVER after the book blew up and was picked up by traditional publishing by then she wouldve fully understood like what was happening and the content of her book so i blame her now. but i dont blame her 18 yr old self that first wrote the book if that makes sense. thats just my opinion on it but imo there are some extremely amazing teen authors who have enough common sense to not blatantly plagiarize (like maryam you all should see her book omg the most creative and original thing ever i love it)
maryam wrote: "@Minnie I MISSED YOU SO MUCH MORE HOW ARE YOUU?? 😚"ITS BEEN GOOD PRETTY EXHAUSTING BUT GOOD WBUU
@minnie WOW YOU REALLY SAID UNPOPULAR LMAO 😭 I kind of disagree because she admitted to using ai to make her sentences longer and to make them sound more poetic. she has ideas yes, despite these ideas being plagiarised, I believe that Lauren loves to read and she wrote what she loves to read, which she has every right to do so. but she shouldn't have published it or accepted that publishing deal when she knows that her work is plagiarized. but I do agree with the second part when you blamed her and said she should understand the consequences of plagiarizing especially since the book got picked up by a publishing company. her being 18 isn't an excuse like you mentioned that there are so many teen authors who are aware that they shouldn't plagiarize. omg thank you so much I love u 🥹 I updated a lot I need to show you !! 💋
@minnie im so sorry hopefully you'll be able to relax soon !! I've been good but exhausted as well ! 💋
maryam wrote: "@Rory I haven't read it/ watched it but I heard it was just gay porn 😭"it is and there is 0 chemistry or intimacy its just fucking to fuck which is not progressive or good rep 💔💔 + it has a weird thing about like infantilizing/feminizing the wasian character
hate when a series is 1st person pov and stays on one character but on the final book of the series it switches to 3rd person and between different characters
jj (chainsaw) 🐾 wrote: "heated rivalry is boring and EXTREMELY unsexy like not an ounce of eroticism there ☺️🩷"marvel needs us as the next big woke
to me, my hr haters
we should start making some book adaptations into animated movies/shows (mature ones) instead of always making it live. for example, it'd lowkey be cool to see ouabh in an animated form instead of live action yk 🥲 they'd have to REALLY pull it off
@Ellie YESYESYES. or make them into video games I'd love for my book to become a video game thats's so fucking cool. ouabh in old Disney style would be so amazing !!
heated rivalry is extremely overrated (jj and rory pls marry me) audiobooks count as reading, all books have the potential to be adapted into some sort of film but it's definitely not successful 100% of the time, off campus> heated rivalry, the rose bargain is underrated and should've won a gr award, i should be allowed to rate my dnfs if i make it past 50%, etc. 💋
> I think the reason the show blew up and was so good is mostly because of Jacob Tierney (director) and not Rachel Reid (author). The books are generic at best and that is why JT was free to do whatever with his own vision. It would be the same if it was any other hockey mm romance but it wouldn't be the same in quality without Jacob Tierney.> Brandon Sanderson isn't a good writer (prose, tone, characters), he's a good worldbuilder. His actual books are overall good though.
> Heartstopper is very, very, overrated and has representation for the sake of it without any characters having any actual personality. The show is better, as someone who read all of it long before it.
> I dislike all myth/fairytale retellings and think they should steer AWAY from the source. If it's a retelling, there's always something to complain about and they're all the same and wildly inaccurate at the sane time. (Yes I have a grudge against TSoA and Circe).
> Speaking of myths, I DESPISE Emily Wilson's translation of The Odyssey (and Illiad but I'm not informed on it so I won't speak of it). It is everywhere and it is a horrific translation that strips the text of all its poetic language and lyricism. It is a bastardisation of the work. I wouldn't have such a problem with it if it weren't for the fact that any other translations are now impossible to find both online and for purchase. Wilson's translation is the worst one by far and it is not a close comparison and everyone keeps praising it. I do think it has merit, like all translations, but again, it is EVERYWHERE and I cannot stand it.
@margot yes audiobooks do count as reading as long as you're consuming the words you did read it. I do agree with the adaptation opinion but if the adaptation isn't properly executed then it shouldn't be released. I didn't watch or read or read either to form an opinion 😭 YESYESYES LOUDER FOR THE ROSE BARGAIN. you should be allowed to rate your dnfs no matter how far you're into the book you did technically consume it and maybe you hated it because of the writing and you gave the writing a bad rating so you should be allowed to rate dnfs.
@dream omg hi dream long time no see! I agree! there are so many mm hockey books. it doesn't matter who writes them it matters who picks them up and makes an adaptation. he's on my tbr so I'll have to get back to you on that when I read his books! but I haven't heard that opinion about him before. I haven't watched or read heart stopper 😔 but I've never heard that opinion before since people usually have nothing but praise for the show and books. YESYESYYES!! they don't do retellings well and steer them away from the actual plot. (yes im referencing tvd I hate that book it wasn't a Romeo and Juliette retelling at all it was just called that for the sake of marketing. the Odessy is on my tbr because I want to watch the movie so I can't form an opinion or speak on that either 😔





