Erin’s Reviews > The Hound of the Baskervilles & The Valley of Fear > Status Update
Erin
is on page 173 of 424
Chapter 12 - Death on the Moor
I was right about it being Sherlock! My theory about the Mrs. Lyons was wrong, but this makes up for that.
Additonally, I knew that Stapleton was suspicious! He was planning on having Sir Henry killed that night; inviting him over then letting out the hound. Thankfully, Henry was smart and didn't go out. I wonder why he wants the Baskervilles dead? Hopefully we get our answers soon!
— Jun 08, 2026 12:51AM
I was right about it being Sherlock! My theory about the Mrs. Lyons was wrong, but this makes up for that.
Additonally, I knew that Stapleton was suspicious! He was planning on having Sir Henry killed that night; inviting him over then letting out the hound. Thankfully, Henry was smart and didn't go out. I wonder why he wants the Baskervilles dead? Hopefully we get our answers soon!
Like flag
Erin’s Previous Updates
Erin
is on page 400 of 424
Part 2, Chapter 7
I figured that McMurdo was Mr. Douglas, but I did not realize that he was also Birdy Edwards! What a twist!
— Jun 19, 2026 12:00AM
I figured that McMurdo was Mr. Douglas, but I did not realize that he was also Birdy Edwards! What a twist!
Erin
is on page 400 of 424
Part 2: Chapter 6 - Danger
I have a bad feeling about this.
— Jun 18, 2026 10:15AM
I have a bad feeling about this.
Erin
is on page 362 of 424
Part 2: Chapter 4 - The Valley of Fear
I feel bad for Morris, and I think that McMurdo should take his warning; these are not good people to be getting into bed with, and now that McMurdo is involved with them. I don't think it will be easy to get out, seeing how much influence they have in town.
— Jun 16, 2026 10:56AM
I feel bad for Morris, and I think that McMurdo should take his warning; these are not good people to be getting into bed with, and now that McMurdo is involved with them. I don't think it will be easy to get out, seeing how much influence they have in town.
Erin
is on page 362 of 424
Part 2: Chapter 3 -Lodge 341, Vermissa
So this Baldwin is proving to be trouble, but we already knew that from part one. McMurdo is definitely putting himself on Baldwins shitlist too. I wonder if McMurdo is Mr. Douglas, because he hasn't shown up yet.
I feel that joining this organization was such a bad idea too.
— Jun 16, 2026 12:27AM
So this Baldwin is proving to be trouble, but we already knew that from part one. McMurdo is definitely putting himself on Baldwins shitlist too. I wonder if McMurdo is Mr. Douglas, because he hasn't shown up yet.
I feel that joining this organization was such a bad idea too.
Erin
is on page 343 of 424
Part 2: Chapter 2
These Scowrers do not seem to be people I would want to be around, but McMurdo seems to be there type of people. I'm also wondering where Mr. Douglas is in all of this.
— Jun 15, 2026 11:14AM
These Scowrers do not seem to be people I would want to be around, but McMurdo seems to be there type of people. I'm also wondering where Mr. Douglas is in all of this.
Erin
is on page 325 of 424
Part 2: Chapter 1 - The Man
I think McMurdo is making a mistake; getting involved with this Scanlan.
— Jun 14, 2026 11:54PM
I think McMurdo is making a mistake; getting involved with this Scanlan.
Erin
is on page 312 of 424
Chapter 7 - The Solution
HE WASN'T DEAD! I would never have suspected that. I am glad to see that Mrs. Douglas and Mr. Barker had nothing to do with Mr. Douglas' murder.
I do look forward to reading about what happend in "The Valley of Fear"
— Jun 14, 2026 11:27AM
HE WASN'T DEAD! I would never have suspected that. I am glad to see that Mrs. Douglas and Mr. Barker had nothing to do with Mr. Douglas' murder.
I do look forward to reading about what happend in "The Valley of Fear"
Erin
is on page 294 of 424
Chapter 6 - A Dawning Light
So Mrs. Douglas and Mr. Barker are definitely involved somehow.
I wonder what Sherlock's words to Watson after coming into the room after his investigation mean.
— Jun 12, 2026 10:29AM
So Mrs. Douglas and Mr. Barker are definitely involved somehow.
I wonder what Sherlock's words to Watson after coming into the room after his investigation mean.
Erin
is on page 278 of 424
Chapter 5 - The People of the Drama
So the bloodmark on the sill was made by Barker; I knew he was suspicious!! And Mrs. Douglas seems rather suspicious herself. Maybe she had something to do with it? Is it to do with Mr. Douglas being so jealous? And how does this secret society fit in?
— Jun 11, 2026 11:55PM
So the bloodmark on the sill was made by Barker; I knew he was suspicious!! And Mrs. Douglas seems rather suspicious herself. Maybe she had something to do with it? Is it to do with Mr. Douglas being so jealous? And how does this secret society fit in?
Erin
is on page 264 of 424
Chapter 4 - Darkness
Finally! Sherlock is on the case. The possible secret society is where Moriarty is connected, I assume.
If the murderer had a bicycle, why did he leave it behind.
I have no theories yet.
— Jun 11, 2026 10:24AM
Finally! Sherlock is on the case. The possible secret society is where Moriarty is connected, I assume.
If the murderer had a bicycle, why did he leave it behind.
I have no theories yet.
