Mathis Carneiro’s Reviews > A Good Animal > Status Update
Like flag
Mathis’s Previous Updates
Mathis Carneiro
is on page 215 of 288
second half is much better than the first
— Jul 06, 2026 04:44PM
Mathis Carneiro
is on page 165 of 288
okay I’m kind of vibing with it now only took like half the book😭
— Jul 06, 2026 09:57AM
Mathis Carneiro
is on page 97 of 288
okay first few pages of part 2 and I can tell that it’s starting to get good now, part 1 was a bit rough🥴
— Jul 04, 2026 12:13PM
Mathis Carneiro
is on page 89 of 288
boring. yawning. sloppy. okay not “sloppy” I kind of like the writing but the only reason I’m not dnf-ing is because I’ve seen reviews that say the second half is where it starts to get better because so far it’s just a whole lotta farm culture and a whole lotta nothing of what I thought this book was gonna be😭🙏
— Jul 03, 2026 03:40PM
Mathis Carneiro
is on page 61 of 288
I have no idea what this book is trying to be, and I don’t think it knows either. we were introduced to our main characters + Mary (love interest) in the first chapter, and then we just went into a whole different direction and it’s been like thirty pages of some stupid lamb contest or some shi
— Jul 03, 2026 02:51PM
Mathis Carneiro
is on page 19 of 288
just started this, and usually when im only a few pages into a book, the very first thing I notice is if I will enjoy the writing or now. and the answer is…maybe? im conflicted
— Jul 02, 2026 04:08PM

