Matthew McElroy ’s Reviews > The Iliad > Status Update
Matthew McElroy
is on page 100 of 462
Seeing as this has been in the public domain since... well, I guess this literally started in the public domain. "Hey, you wanna here a story about that crazy war that just happened?"
Anyway... this is a fantastic edition. The Introduction is exceedingly helpful. There are historical clarifications, tips about phrasing, and what similes mean.
— Jul 25, 2026 05:43PM
Anyway... this is a fantastic edition. The Introduction is exceedingly helpful. There are historical clarifications, tips about phrasing, and what similes mean.
2 likes · Like flag
Matthew’s Previous Updates
Matthew McElroy
is on page 348 of 462
If a high school student told me they didn't enjoy The Iliad, I would ask why, but I would understand their reasoning.
In the middle of the book, there about 100 pages (10 chapters?) of war. Well-described fighting, but largely violence. We get motivation and personal conflict, but it is mostly people getting slaughtered.
I just got to the turning point of the book, where Achilles has made peace with Agamemnon.
— 9 hours, 0 min ago
In the middle of the book, there about 100 pages (10 chapters?) of war. Well-described fighting, but largely violence. We get motivation and personal conflict, but it is mostly people getting slaughtered.
I just got to the turning point of the book, where Achilles has made peace with Agamemnon.
Matthew McElroy
is on page 230 of 462
These guys love fighting. I mean loving it. And Homer is all in on the fighting. He is happy to describe the way a spear went through someone's body- head, back, stomach, whatever. One of the major aspects of the story that makes it transformative is that the gods largely act like humans. They aren't human. And in Reiu's introduction, he makes it clear that the humans respect and fear the gods.
— Aug 01, 2026 07:55AM
Matthew McElroy
is on page 150 of 462
Zeus loves being involved in the daily lives of humans, especially when they are beautiful young women minding their own damned business. But in the biggest war we know of in Greek mythology/history, Zeus tells all the gods, "No. Not this time."
— Jul 28, 2026 06:16AM

