E’s Reviews > The Silent Companions > Status Update
E
is on page 107 of 305
Hmmmm, this is what I was worried about. As much as I liked the vibes in the asylum, I think she should have cut that timeline if she wanted to flash back to Anne because this feels a little too scattered. Or maybe it's that Elsie is an interesting character and Anne isn't? It could be because I read the other book but I didn't really need any more of Anne's story. But maybe it will surprise me.
— Sep 05, 2026 08:10AM
Like flag
E’s Previous Updates
E
is on page 268 of 305
Elsie is unconscious for so many events, why do that to your main POV character?
— Sep 08, 2026 08:51PM
E
is on page 216 of 305
I am so glad I didn't read this one first because I am not sure I would have read the prequel. It's missing so much of the character work that the other one included and I think this one actually needs it more because there is a lot less happening plot-wise. Elsie is the only interesting character.
— Sep 07, 2026 09:56PM
E
is on page 153 of 305
The 1600s are super boring. I feel like Joleon is Elsie's and she murdered her father? I mean there has got to be at least one secret child.
— Sep 06, 2026 09:16PM
E
is on page 65 of 305
Vibes are excellent. I wonder why in both cases she went with pregnant character? Though Elsie and Belinda luckily feel like very different characters. I like the creep factor of the asylum but I worry that once she introduces Anne's story it will get a little unwieldy with 3 different timelines.
— Aug 29, 2026 02:37PM