Rose Rosetree’s Reviews > Brilliance > Status Update

Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is on page 10 of 11
Much as I admire Marcus Sakey, I think this book could have used a good editor. I can't wait for this ordeal to be over.


Did you know, Goodreaders? I've heard tell that even the most prestigious publishers seldom include the services of a professional editor. And the author must usually pay for a publicist, too.
— Sep 27, 2026 04:06PM
Brilliance (Brilliance Saga, #1)

10 likes ·  flag

Rose’s Previous Updates

Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is on page 8 of 11
Thrill is added to thrill. I found the hero's solo mission, including how he counted the minutes, to be credible and inspiring.
— Sep 26, 2026 04:55PM
Brilliance (Brilliance Saga, #1)


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is on page 7 of 11
By law, the only form of business that Jews were allowed to do was moneylending. This supposedly shameful kind of work had to be done by someone, so the Jews were forced to do it.

Those stereotypes about Jews being greedy or miserly were part of the same Anti-Semitic cruelty. Undeserved. Disgusting.

If you didn't know about this, there are plenty of websites that will tell you the truth.

(Part 3)
— Sep 25, 2026 04:05PM
Brilliance (Brilliance Saga, #1)


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is on page 7 of 11
This is tne most Anti-Semitic writing I have seen anywhere, let alone a novel.

If Marcus Sakey ever, ever!, writes more in this vein, I will boycott him as an author.

ABOUT THOSE COMMON STEREOTYPES ABOUT JEWS

In many countries, for hundreds of years, the Jewish population had to live in ghettoes.

(Part 2)
— Sep 25, 2026 04:01PM
Brilliance (Brilliance Saga, #1)


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is on page 7 of 11
Much as I love this book, and plan to finish it, one thing has really shocked.

A minor character runs a sweatshop where Brilliants work for the sweatshop owner in a truly exploitative relationship. A cruel and mercenary relationship.

We learn in detail about his greed and cruelty. He is referred to by his last name, a recognizably Jewish name.

(Part 1)
— Sep 25, 2026 03:58PM
Brilliance (Brilliance Saga, #1)


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is on page 5 of 11
Another main character can walk through crowds as though invisible.

Back in the day, while doing the TM Sidhi Program, one of the sutras I'd do was for INVISIBILITY. I sure never came close to what is described, in believable detail, in this book.
— Sep 24, 2026 04:56PM
Brilliance (Brilliance Saga, #1)


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is on page 5 of 11
I'm fascinated by the author's descriptions of different ways of perceiving life, and accomplishing things, as a "Twist." An "Abnorm." Part of a generation of ultra-smart people.

The main character, Cooper, is superb at reading people through minute changes to how they hold their bodies.

I wish the book weren't so violent, but I put up with that to learn about others.
— Sep 24, 2026 04:54PM
Brilliance (Brilliance Saga, #1)


No comments have been added yet.