Toadroad’s Reviews > All Hallows Eve > Status Update
Toadroad
is starting
#10 - 5 stars. this wasn’t really a horror story, but it’s set on Halloween. This made me want to read more Alma Katsu.
— Oct 21, 2026 01:12PM
Like flag
Toadroad’s Previous Updates
Toadroad
is starting
#19 - 4 stars. I liked this story. I do think that the collection should’ve ended with a shorter story and one that is even more Halloween themed.
— Oct 25, 2026 01:01PM
Toadroad
is starting
#18 - 5 stars. this story was great. I actually typically really really really don’t like stories of people being eaten, and this one should’ve turned me off due to how graphic it is, but I like Ballingrud’s writing and it might be my favorite of the bunch. My one wish is that they described how the ghouls looked more.
— Oct 25, 2026 10:31AM
Toadroad
is starting
#17 - 4 stars. I was loving this one and thought it would be 5 stars. Then it went on a page and half too long and ended in a less satisfying way. Still, it got me looking forward to reading more Richard Kadrey.
— Oct 24, 2026 04:33PM
Toadroad
is starting
#15 - 4 stars. I liked this one up until the end. I don’t understand what is meant by the very last sentence and it seems like it supposed to be meaningful, which frustrates me.
#16 - 4 stars. A rare horror story about old people. I’m conflicted. I feel that the brevity of this story worked to its advantage, but it would’ve been more satisfying if fleshed out more.
— Oct 24, 2026 03:49PM
#16 - 4 stars. A rare horror story about old people. I’m conflicted. I feel that the brevity of this story worked to its advantage, but it would’ve been more satisfying if fleshed out more.
Toadroad
is starting
#13 - 4.5 stars. I really liked the premise of this story. Solid ending.
#14 - 5 stars. Never heard of this author before, but this was awesome.
— Oct 24, 2026 01:34PM
#14 - 5 stars. Never heard of this author before, but this was awesome.
Toadroad
is starting
#12 - 3.75 stars. I admittedly didn’t quite understand what was happening with regards to the horror/supernatural element. However, the backdrop of the Irish famine was excellent and the despair conveyed well.
— Oct 22, 2026 11:03PM
Toadroad
is starting
#9 - 4.5 stars. I typically enjoy Christopher Golden and this was no exception. I thought it would get 5 stars, but the end is just too heavy-handed.
— Oct 21, 2026 12:34PM
Toadroad
is starting
#8 - 3 stars. This was a poem, not a story. It was very short, but ultimately I liked it.
— Oct 21, 2026 12:09PM

