Abby Rose’s Reviews > In These Hallowed Halls: A Dark Academia Anthology > Status Update
Abby Rose
is on page 25 of 340
1000 Ships by Kate Weinberg
2/5 stars. Not a good start to the anthology, which is a shame because the setup of this story wasn’t bad, but the half-baked ending and following author’s note tells us it’s actually a prequel to her novel. I find that not only lazy but also quite disrespectful to the book’s chosen medium.
— Oct 21, 2026 03:27PM
2/5 stars. Not a good start to the anthology, which is a shame because the setup of this story wasn’t bad, but the half-baked ending and following author’s note tells us it’s actually a prequel to her novel. I find that not only lazy but also quite disrespectful to the book’s chosen medium.
1 like · Like flag
Abby’s Previous Updates
Abby Rose
is on page 329 of 340
Phobos by Tori Bovalino.
2/5 stars. This doesn’t have the development to mean anything and feels more like an author threw darts at a dark academia trope board.
— Oct 30, 2026 09:15PM
2/5 stars. This doesn’t have the development to mean anything and feels more like an author threw darts at a dark academia trope board.
Abby Rose
is on page 302 of 340
The Professor of Ontography
4/5 stars, would fit well in a Halloween collection.
— Oct 29, 2026 01:27PM
4/5 stars, would fit well in a Halloween collection.
Abby Rose
is on page 267 of 340
Weekend at Bertie’s by ML Rio.
2.5 stars. Having never read from this author before but knowing her reputation, I found this pretty lacking. I didn’t care enough about the characters to find the plot (which is mostly waiting in a big house) engaging, and I don’t see much in the way of themes besides multiple Poe references.
— Oct 29, 2026 12:33PM
2.5 stars. Having never read from this author before but knowing her reputation, I found this pretty lacking. I didn’t care enough about the characters to find the plot (which is mostly waiting in a big house) engaging, and I don’t see much in the way of themes besides multiple Poe references.
Abby Rose
is on page 235 of 340
The Unknowable Pleasures by Susie Yang.
Hmmmm. I’m having a tough time with this one because I previously read White Ivy by this author and felt iffy on the treatment of homosexuality in it. Here, again, I feel iffy, and it’s harder to separate the art from the artist with already a strike against her.
Leaning toward a low rating, probably a 2 😕
— Oct 27, 2026 02:09PM
Hmmmm. I’m having a tough time with this one because I previously read White Ivy by this author and felt iffy on the treatment of homosexuality in it. Here, again, I feel iffy, and it’s harder to separate the art from the artist with already a strike against her.
Leaning toward a low rating, probably a 2 😕
Abby Rose
is on page 205 of 340
Four Funerals by David Bell
4/5 stars. A different yet necessary take on dark academia in the modern day
— Oct 26, 2026 10:17PM
4/5 stars. A different yet necessary take on dark academia in the modern day
Abby Rose
is on page 177 of 340
The Ravages by Layne Fargo
4/5. Yay for messy gays 🩷
— Oct 26, 2026 08:06PM
4/5. Yay for messy gays 🩷
Abby Rose
is on page 152 of 340
X House by JT Ellison.
2/5 stars. This just wasn’t long enough to explore the plot and themes it wanted to.
— Oct 26, 2026 07:38PM
2/5 stars. This just wasn’t long enough to explore the plot and themes it wanted to.
Abby Rose
is on page 125 of 340
The Hare and the Hound by Kelly Andrew.
2.5/5. Wish there was some more nuance to this predictable story. Also, when did we start writing the word brows as ‘brows?? Let’s not.
— Oct 26, 2026 06:26PM
2.5/5. Wish there was some more nuance to this predictable story. Also, when did we start writing the word brows as ‘brows?? Let’s not.
Abby Rose
is on page 85 of 340
Sabbatical by James Tate Hill
3/5. Kinda silly, not so much the dark academia vibe. But I found very very end quite clever.
— Oct 26, 2026 02:56PM
3/5. Kinda silly, not so much the dark academia vibe. But I found very very end quite clever.

