Arian’s Reviews > The Idiot > Status Update

Arian
Arian is on page 590 of 768
I thoroughly enjoyed reading the general's personal (but fantastical of course) narrative of Napoleon's march into Moscow. He opens his account by clarifying to the prince that he was 10 years old 'because as a 15 year old I would not have run away from our wooden house on Staraya Basmannaya on the day of Napoleon's entrance to Moscow, leaving my mother, who was too late to leave Moscow, and trembling with fear...
— 3 hours, 27 min ago
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)

flag

Arian’s Previous Updates

Arian
Arian is on page 562 of 768
The opening of the final part of the story focuses on the 'commonplace' characters of our story. The narrator speaks of Gavrila, 'indeed, there is nothing more vexing, for example, than to be wealthy, of decent family, of decent appearance, not badly educated, not stupid, even kind-hearted, and at the same time to possess no talent, no special quality, nor even any eccentricity, not a single idea of one's own...
— Oct 26, 2026 05:24AM
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)


Arian
Arian is on page 537 of 768
As I’m on the final part of the story I think this is a good moment to reflect a little. It’s taken me awhile to get to this point (close to five months) and it’s bcos of the philosophy woven into the narrative. This is the most challenging novel I’ve read, emotionally and intellectually, and I’m glad I’ve taken my sweet time. I look forward to the endgame!
— Oct 13, 2026 06:11AM
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)


Arian
Arian is on page 510 of 768
‘Let us allow that the spark of consciousness was lit by the will of a higher power, let us allow that it was suddenly instructed by that higher power to destroy itself, because for some reason - and the reason was not even explained - that’s just how it was up there, let us allow, I admit all that, but there still remains the eternal question: why is my meekness demanded in all this?…
— Oct 08, 2026 02:42PM
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)


Arian
Arian is on page 480 of 768
‘Individual kindness will always remain, because it is a need of the personality, a living need for the direct influence of one personality on another. (…) How can you know, Bakhmutov, what significance this communication between one personality and another may have in the fate of the personality that is communicated with?….
— Sep 29, 2026 12:56AM
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)


Arian
Arian is on page 461 of 768
Without a doubt, Ippolit is the most tragic character I have ever read. In his 'NECESSARY EXPLANATION' (which I suspect is his suicide note) writes about 'the idea that it was not worth living for a few weeks (..) and that the first moment that this thought penetrated me completely and directly was at the very same moment when it occurred to me to sample life for the last time, and I wanted to see people and trees...
— Sep 13, 2026 02:23PM
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)


Arian
Arian is on page 428 of 768
I'll admit that I've read too much without updating my progress (it's gotten so good). Rogozhin and the Prince meet for the first time since 'you made an attempt on my life', says Myshkin. The Prince reaffirms Rogozhin, saying, 'the only Rogozhin I remember is the one with whom I exchanged crosses as a brother that day; I wrote that to you in my letter yesterday, so that you'd stop thinking about all that delirium'.
— Aug 30, 2026 12:42PM
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)


Arian
Arian is on page 377 of 768
I really enjoyed reading Keller's confession to the Prince. Keller says to the Prince after he revealed his true motive 'by means of tears', 'Well, that's how to flabbergast a man completely! For pity's sake, Prince: such simple-heartedness, such innocence as were unheard of even in the golden age, and then suddenly you pierce a man through like an arrow, with such profound psychology of observation.'
— Aug 24, 2026 10:32AM
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)


Arian
Arian is on page 352 of 768
'Yes, nature is given to mocking! Why does she create the very finest beings just in order to mock them? Was it she who made it so that (...) she destined him to say things on account of which so much blood was shed that it it were shed all at once people would probably have drowned in it? Oh, it's good that I am dying! I would also probably have uttered some horrible lie, nature would have betrayed me like that!'
— Aug 23, 2026 02:11PM
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)


Arian
Arian is on page 323 of 768
A man claiming to be the rightful heir to the prince's fortune declares his 'human right, a natural one; the right of common sense and the voice of conscience, and even though this right of ours is not written down in any rotten human code of law, a decent and honest man is obliged to remain a decent and honest man even on those points that aren't written down in the law books.'
— Aug 22, 2026 09:25AM
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)


Arian
Arian is on page 292 of 768
During a discussion among the Yepanchin sisters and a few others, Aglaya Ivanovna refers to a 12th-Century tradition where a knight devoted himself to a noble lady, 'that even if later she became a thief, he would still be bound to believe in her and break a lance for her pure beauty.' This comes after Koyla refers to Ganya as the 'poor knight' to (presumably) Nastasya Fillipovna.
— Aug 14, 2026 06:24AM
The Idiot (Penguin Classics)


Comments Showing 1-3 of 3 (3 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Arian (new) - added it

Arian At fifteen I’d have been afraid, but at ten I was afraid of nothing and pushed my way through the crowd right up to the front steps of the palace just as Napoleon was getting off his horse.’


message 2: by Arian (new) - added it

Arian The general goes on: ‘Suddenly Napoleon's gaze happened to fall on me, and a strange thought fleeted in his eyes. “Child!” he said to me suddenly. "How do you suppose: if I accept Orthodoxy and free your serfs, will the Russians follow me?" "Never!" I exclaimed in indignation. Napoleon was struck. "In the eyes of this child, shining with patriotism," he said, "I have read the opinion of the entire Russian people. Enough, Davoust! This is all fantasies! Let me hear your other plan.” (…) Of course, it was a Napoleonic idea, an aquiline idea, but the other plan was also an idea... That was the famous "Conseil du lion", as Napoleon himself called Davoust's plan. It consisted in them barricading themselves inside the Kremlin with all the troops, building bar-racks, digging fortifications, positioning cannon, slaughtering as many horses as possible and salting their flesh; obtaining or plundering grain, and holding out all winter until the spring; and in spring, breaking through the Russian lines. This plan strongly attracted Napoleon. Every day we rode round the Kremlin walls, he would indicate where we should demolish, where we should build, where we should construct the lunettes, the ravelins, the blockhouses - one glance, then swiftness and thrust! At last, it was all decided; Davoust pressed for a final decision. Again they were alone together, and I was the third person present. Again Napoleon paced up and down the room, his arms folded. I couldn't take my eyes off his face, and my heart was thumping. "I'm going," said Davoust. "Where to?" asked Napoleon. "To salt the horses," said Davoust. Napoleon shuddered; his fate was being decided. "Child!" he said to me suddenly. "What do you think of our plan?" Of course, he asked the question in the way that, on occasion, a man of the greatest intellect, will at the last moment resort to heads or tails. Instead of Napoleon, I turned to Davoust and spoke like one inspired: "Go home, General!" The plan was ruined.’


message 3: by Arian (new) - added it

Arian ‘But I repeat to you, I was a witness of that great man's nocturnal tears and groans; but absolutely no one saw that, except me! Towards the end, it's true, he didn't weep at all, there were no tears, he merely groaned sometimes; but his face seemed more and more clouded by darkness. It was as though eternity were already spreading her dark wing over him. Sometimes, at night, we spent whole hours alone, in silence - the Mameluke Rustan would be snoring in the next room; that man slept awfully soundly. "But he's loyal to me and to the dynasty,” Napoleon would say of him. On one occasion it all became too terribly painful, and he suddenly noticed the tears
in my eyes; he gave me a look of tender emotion
“You feel sorry for me!" he exclaimed. "You, a child, and perhaps there's another child who will feel sorry for me - my son, le roi de Rome; all the others, they all hate me, and my brothers will be the first to sell me into slavery!" I began to sob and rushed to him; at that point he himself broke down; we embraced, and our tears mingled. “Write, write to the Empress Josephine!" I sobbed to him. Napoleon gave a shudder, thought, and said to me: “You have reminded me of another heart that loves me; I thank you, mon ami!" He sat right down and wrote the letter to Josephine with which Constant was dispatched the next day. “You did well,” said the prince. “Amidst cruel thoughts, you led him to kind feeling.”’


back to top