Amr Ojjeh’s Reviews > The Crucifixion and the Qur'an: A Study in the History of Muslim Thought > Status Update
Like flag
Amr’s Previous Updates
Amr Ojjeh
is on page 68 of 256
Fascinating discussion of the pre-Tabari commentaries. Most related a substitution theory, of which some of were voluntary and others were retributive (former was preferred). Some commentators were silent on the matter, and some focused on surprisingly tangential points, such as the meaning of "yaqin" and "ma qataluhu."
— Nov 03, 2026 12:26PM
Amr Ojjeh
is on page 40 of 256
Finished ch1. Not entirely convinced by the alternative interpretations, but the thesis of the chapter, which is that the verse is not definitive on the question of historical crucifixion, is well argued.
In particular, however, I struggle to see how q-t-l in 4:157 can refer to the "khuld" (eternal nature; soul) of Jesus. Ch3 will likely go into more detail.
— Nov 02, 2026 06:21PM
In particular, however, I struggle to see how q-t-l in 4:157 can refer to the "khuld" (eternal nature; soul) of Jesus. Ch3 will likely go into more detail.

