Jesse’s Reviews > The Three Impostors or the Transmutations > Status Update

“Adventure of the Deserted Residence”

HOLY SHIT

Dyson and Phillips stalk through a wealth of imagery about decay and decadence before coming across the body of the man with the spectacles. It’s, uh, a powerful note to end on.

“Strange Occurrence in Clerkenwell”

Dyson is led by the bent of the universe to witness an act mentioned in the prologue—when Davies touches him on the arm. We are indeed close to the end, and now we get the first honest bit of backstory, the journal of the guy with the glasses. Cool! Not to say that I minded the weird stories of the con-people.

“Novel of the White Powder”

Dang! This woman tells the GOOD stories. Her overworked brother starts to take a drug to assist with his health. He starts to look like he feels better, the he starts to feel TOO good for his sister’s liking, as he is constantly partying with a man he used to know, Orford, and living a life of decadence and not studying his law books. Things Get Worse.

“The Recluse of Baywater”

Dyson has a realistic novelist friend who he visits every so often. The normally vacant first floor apartment has been taken… by a lady! By the same lady that accosted Phillips, of course, but under a different name. The con-woman appeals to Dyson’s sense of adventure, suggesting that she is in mortal peril, which Wilkins utterly failed to do with his Novel.

“Novel of the Iron Maid”

This is a short horror tale. Burton has to walk nine miles after missing his train and is found by an acquaintance about halfway there. The dude takes him to his house and wants to show him his OWN collection. It turns out that Mathias collects instruments of torture! Okay, weird, but Burton nevertheless tags along as he shows off his latest item, a clockwork statue called the Iron Maid.

“The Decorative Imagination”

This is a framing story to describe how Dyson and Burton become frequent friends, leading to the next Novel. Presumably Wilkins disappeared because he could tell that Dyson had sniffed out the incongruities of his stories. In any case, Dyson specifically mentions the decadent trend and even novels about “old women” and “new women”, so he was clearly hip to the trends.

“Incident of the Private Bar”

We meet the third imposter! He isn’t the guy that Dyson saw chasing the guy with the glasses, so on reading back in the prologue, the trio referenced a fourth conspirator, Lipsius. Anyway, this dude has a thematically interesting story to tell as he is a collector of curios and he freely admits to using conman techniques, including lurid stories, to grease his purchases.

“Novel of the Black Seal”

The story of “Lally” is so much cooler than Richmond’s. Lally is rescued from starvation by the ethnologist and employed as his governess. She has some level of self-education and eventually becomes Gregg’s secretary as well, assisting him with some of his research, culminating with his obsession with locating a lost race, perhaps of Atlantis.

“Adventure of the Missing Brother”

This time we have Phillips, and he is preyed upon by the woman impersonator. She is pretending to look for her brother, describing him as the young man with the glasses. She tells a very short story where she sees him at their usual Saturday rendezvous point only for him to be escorted past her by what appears to be a dead man, and receiving a telepathic communication.

“The Novel of the Dark Valley”

A harrowing tale of a man who becomes the unwitting secretary to the head of a nefarious gang in America, only to be saved at the last second from being lynched as a gang member. Dyson takes this story in stride, but as a wise man, he infers that this Wilkins does not actually fear this spectacled man who he calls Jack Smith. That’s a pretty good character beat!