Olivia Tonn’s Reviews > The Mermaid in the Basement > Status Update
Olivia Tonn
is 95% done
“You’re the one who killed Kate Fairfield! You’re Secret Lover!”
I fear I shall never take this book seriously 😭
— Nov 14, 2026 09:40PM
I fear I shall never take this book seriously 😭
Like flag
Olivia’s Previous Updates
Olivia Tonn
is 97% done
“His wide, mobile lips were smiling”
Oh my sweet grandmother’s biscuits and gravy, what have I just read?
It’s a mouth, not a car.
— Nov 14, 2026 09:43PM
Oh my sweet grandmother’s biscuits and gravy, what have I just read?
It’s a mouth, not a car.
Olivia Tonn
is 4% done
HELP. I’ve just realized the male lead talks like Yoda. I will not be recovering from this. 😭
— Nov 14, 2026 07:08PM
Olivia Tonn
is 4% done
The writing quality of this book is not very good at all, and yet I love it. I think we’ve established that Gilbert Morris is my one weak spot 😂
— Nov 14, 2026 07:04PM
Olivia Tonn
is starting
IT’S HERE. I HAVE IT.
I finally have my hands on another Gilbert Morris book (HUGE thanks to my friend who told me about this series and with whom I’m buddy reading it!) and I am SO excited to get going.
Here’s hoping this series is basically just a regurgitation of Cheney and Shiloh except set in the Victorian era!
— Nov 14, 2026 05:50PM
I finally have my hands on another Gilbert Morris book (HUGE thanks to my friend who told me about this series and with whom I’m buddy reading it!) and I am SO excited to get going.
Here’s hoping this series is basically just a regurgitation of Cheney and Shiloh except set in the Victorian era!

