Maxwell Gu’s Reviews > Montana 1948 > Status Update
Maxwell Gu
is on page 31 of 186
Watson manipulates the story by making Marie refuse to see a doctor, and I am wondering why Larry Watson would add that part. Is it because she knows something that the others don't? Why would a sick woman refuse a free doctor? Watson is setting something up, and I predict that maybe a doctor would do something bad to a Native American woman at this time, and Uncle Frank did something bad that the others don't know?
— Nov 19, 2026 06:29PM
Like flag
Maxwell’s Previous Updates
Maxwell Gu
is on page 43 of 186
Watson manipulates the story by having an older David tell it, letting him hint at disaster and build suspense. He makes Frank a hero everyone loves, so the truth shocks the reader and the characters. Watson uses a kind of karma in the parents’ deaths, where Wes, who kept the family’s secret, dies slowly of cancer, while Gail, who stood for the truth, gets a merciful death. Why doesn’t Watson let the law punish them?
— 9 hours, 33 min ago
Maxwell Gu
is on page 43 of 186
Watson manipulates the story by having an older David tell it, letting him hint at disaster and build suspense. He makes Frank a hero everyone loves, so the truth shocks the reader and the characters. Watson uses a kind of karma in the parents’ deaths, where Wes, who kept the family’s secret, dies slowly of cancer, while Gail, who stood for the truth, gets a merciful death. Why doesn’t Watson let the law punish them?
— 9 hours, 33 min ago
Maxwell Gu
is on page 43 of 186
Watson manipulates the story by having an older David tell it, letting him hint at disaster and build suspense. He makes Frank a hero everyone loves, so the truth shocks the reader and the characters. Watson uses a kind of karma in the parents’ deaths, where Wes, who kept the family’s secret, dies slowly of cancer, while Gail, who stood for the truth, gets a merciful death. Why doesn’t Watson let the law punish them?
— 9 hours, 33 min ago
Maxwell Gu
is on page 12 of 186
The author flips the Western sheriff stereotype, as Western sheriffs are typically depicted as tough and brave, but the narrator's father is not like that. He doesn't carry his gun or even his badge, and instead of stopping outlaws, he deals with drunks. I believe Watson is setting up a situation where his father deals with something much bigger, where he has to choose between law and justice.
— Nov 17, 2026 08:35AM

