Oliver Ellis’s Reviews > Montana 1948 > Status Update
Oliver Ellis
is on page 22 of 186
The author purposely made Marie sick to create conflict between Marie and the Hayden family. Once Marie was sick Davies mom interrigated her and asked her all kinds of questions. At first she seemed fine with this until Davies mom brought up the idea of brining Mr. Haydens brother to come check up on her. I wonder if Marie has had some kind of past trauma when it comes to getting help from American doctors.
— Nov 19, 2026 07:07PM
Like flag
Oliver’s Previous Updates
Oliver Ellis
is on page 43 of 186
The author purposely made Uncle Frank the favorite child for a reason. Davies’ dad always listened to his father and never said no, while Frank didn't always do what he was told. Because of this, when Grandfather Hayden asked Davies’ dad to become sheriff, he didn't even consider saying no. Frank, on the other hand, would have refused because he wanted to be a hero and gain fame.
— 9 hours, 45 min ago
Oliver Ellis
is on page 12 of 186
In the prologue the author wrote that there was s young Sioux women in our house. She is feverish, delirious, and coughing so hard I am afraid she will die. This bit of the prologue is a lot like when Nancy got sick in the Shell Collector because she was bitten by a cone shell. The Shell Collector was scared for her life and cared for Nancy deeply, similar to how her dad feared for the Sioux Women.
— Nov 17, 2026 05:46PM

