mantareads’s Reviews > The Man Who Ate the Zoo: Frank Buckland: Forgotten Hero of Natural History > Status Update
mantareads
is on page 232 of 304
Sure, i get it. You need to "historically contextualise". But spending 3-4 pages talking about things that are only distantly linked to the point you're trying to make reads more like lazy editing, excess, and lost-the-plot than "historicizing". Frustrating reading. Can't wait to be done with this book.
— Apr 07, 2020 01:15AM
Like flag
mantareads’s Previous Updates
mantareads
is on page 250 of 304
This is a badly written and badly edited book, and the words are: needless digression. Huge chunks of text could have been trimmed by the simple question of "so what?", a simple question this writer seems to never have asked about his tiresome prose. Many historical texts written by pedants read more substantially and smoothly than this. I'm not sure what is exactly "popular" about such an odious genre.
— Apr 08, 2020 03:28AM
mantareads
is on page 45 of 304
Promising title and interesting life, but 40 pages in, I already realize this book is joylessly written. The author seems bent on cataloguing every detail he can find tiresomely, with no regard for the fluency of the overarching narrative. Reading this for the juicy bits, NOT for the clumsy, clunky writing (the word here could be "pedantic", but I know a lot of pedants who can write more smoothly AND critically)
— Mar 27, 2020 06:30AM
