Sarah Mac’s Reviews > Trades of the Flesh > Status Update
Sarah Mac
is on page 105 of 304
Blech. It’s such a blatant CRIMSON PETAL knock-off, but I could deal with that—or even like it—if the writing wasn’t so awful. Flat, flat, flatter than flat, no depth to anything, no dimension or weight, just perpetual vagueness & flimsy, rushed, amateurish prose. How this got picked up by a major publisher—a Tor imprint, no less!—is beyond me.
— Feb 22, 2021 03:30PM
Like flag
Sarah Mac’s Previous Updates
Sarah Mac
is on page 57 of 304
Feels like a YA version of CRIMSON PETAL—really flat & rushed, no real grit despite the 4-letter words, no true sense of the era beyond trivial description of clothes or media. I can’t say I’m very impressed.
— Feb 22, 2021 01:44AM
