Grace’s Reviews > Herd That > Status Update

Either I'm missing something or this author's editor failed here, but there is a big gaping plot hole thats hard to overlook. In Chap 1, Codie is looking for her grandpas neighbor Mr Valentine whom she assumes is an old man. In Chap 3, Codie says she went to high school with all the Valentine boys who lived next door to her grandpa. Do they have a strangers-meet-cute or a reunion-meet-cute?!?