Donald Scoby’s Reviews > Atlas Shrugged > Status Update
Donald Scoby
is 76% done
I've reached the 'long speech toward the end' I had heard about. GOOD LORD!!! It goes for hours & Hours & HOURS! I understand what Rand was doing, but it's bad for the story -- and it doesn't fit. The 'lesser' people wouldn't listen to such a long broadcast, much less really comprehend it.
— Aug 28, 2021 10:28PM
Like flag
Donald’s Previous Updates
Donald Scoby
is 90% done
S-O C-L-O-S-E to complete! The story took a twist, a necessary twist, that I nearly missed until after the fact -- I think because of the 3-hour long ever livid speech. The book has been fantastic, the point of the speech was integral, but the excessive length hurt the book. Glad to be adding this one to my list of book accomplishments.
— Aug 31, 2021 11:12PM
Donald Scoby
is 77% done
On one hand, we know John can speak -- on the other hand, he has the world's biggest soap box.
— Aug 29, 2021 08:15PM
Donald Scoby
is 70% done
Read a bit of a surprise / not-surprise today. I've been told by another reader that I should be prepared to have my mind blown by the end. Also told there's some long speech. Not sure if I've hit that either. Enjoying the read though. Very timely book.
— Aug 22, 2021 08:59PM
Donald Scoby
is 47% done
Had AR written Fountainhead as she did Atlas Shrugged, I'd have liked it WAY better! Quite enjoying AS, interesting that she wrote it when she did, seeing how it resonates today.
— Aug 12, 2021 08:27PM
Donald Scoby
is 33% done
Much better than Fountainhead, which was mostly a big soap-opera. Atlas Shrugged has better continuity, content has more meaning to story. Interesting to read now, Ayn Rand's writing seems to resonate with modern events.
— Aug 07, 2021 11:29PM
Donald Scoby
is starting
Previously plowed through Fountainhead, which I was told should be covered before Atlas Shrugged. I remain of the opinion that Fountianhead was overwritten. As for Atlas Shrugged, I know it is longer and has its famously long (and wandering?) speech .... so .... we'll see. In any case, I expect to be done with this in about ... probably .... two years. If I cram.
— Jul 22, 2021 10:12AM

