Melani’s Reviews > This Rebel Heart > Status Update
Melani
is 50% done
..a magical girl who spoke to the river and lit a newspaper with magic. I appreciate the symbolism, I think? But I'm not sure how I feel about the symbolism replacing reality? IDK, I'm really conflicted.
— Jun 22, 2022 09:14AM
Like flag
Melani’s Previous Updates
Melani
is 50% done
..she added magical powers to the lives of real people. Neither one of these options really sits well with me. And I'm not quite sure why? I have enjoyed historically based fantasy in the past, but I think the addition of real people, or the replacement of real people is where I draw the line. There were real students who gave 16 demands to the Communist Government in Hungary in 1956. I do not think one of them was..
— Jun 22, 2022 09:12AM
Melani
is 50% done
I'm starting to feel kind of weird about this one. It's fabulously written, and an interesting look at a part of history I'm unfamiliar with. However, I don't know that I like fantasy in my historical fiction. I don't know (and google isn't turning anything up) if the characters in this novel were real people- but the student revolt did happen- and that means either Locke replaced real people with her characters or..
— Jun 22, 2022 09:10AM

