Tiffany’s Reviews > The Further Adventures of Sherlock Holmes - The Moonstone's Curse > Status Update

So, Siciliano seems to be one of THOSE fic writers who absolutely hates one of the canon characters to the point that they create an OC that completely replaces the hated canon character- and exists only to exudes said author's intense hatred for said canon.

I mean... what is the point of writing Sherlock Holmes retellings when you hate one of the most important characters??? FOR NO REASON, TOO!

So, Siciliano seems to be one of THOSE fic writers who absolutely hates one of the canon characters to the point that they create an OC that completely replaces the hated canon character- and exists only to exudes said author's intense hatred for said canon.

I mean... what is the point of writing Sherlock Holmes retellings when you hate one of the most important characters??? FOR NO REASON, TOO!

First let me say that I love the idea of this book and I love that it is inspired by The Moonstone by Wilkie Collins. However, it doesn't have Watson and instead has Dr Henry Vernier as Sherlock's aide. Interesting- but I feel like I need to read the other books written by Siciliano to understand what happened to Watson.

It's fine though. Despite the slight confusion, the writing is enjoyable. About to start Chap 2