maegan’s Reviews > A Court of Mist and Fury > Status Update
20 likes · Like flag
maegan’s Previous Updates
Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Lidia
(new)
-
rated it 1 star
Aug 05, 2023 02:37AM
unfortunately, it should be classified as erotica
reply
|
flag
Not anymore thank god 😂
Teodora wrote: "Not anymore thank god 😂" They chanced? It should be in the erotica genre.
Dyanna wrote: " Teodora wrote: "Not anymore thank god 😂" They chanced? It should be in the erotica genre."Yeah, with the new editions they changed
Teodora wrote: "Dyanna wrote: " Teodora wrote: "Not anymore thank god 😂" They chanced? It should be in the erotica genre."Yeah, with the new editions they changed"
In what genre ?
ACoTaR is 100% NA (new adult), but since it wasn't an official genre back then they categorized it as YA.
Sylvie wrote: "ACoTaR is 100% NA (new adult), but since it wasn't an official genre back then they categorized it as YA."Exactly, but now so many people started writing in that style so it just became a thing
The first I would vote as YA, the second on should be Fantasy NA. Definitely not even close to erotica, though 😅 it’s pretty tame comparatively
Dyanna wrote: " Teodora wrote: "Not anymore thank god 😂" They chanced? It should be in the erotica genre."I think it's pretty tame compared to some erotica out there, but smut and YA definitely don't go together imho
Sylvie wrote: "ACoTaR is 100% NA (new adult), but since it wasn't an official genre back then they categorized it as YA."oh didn't know YA genere didn't exist back in 2015, good to know! But still, I would have classified this as adult, I don't know why they didn't
Bennett wrote: "The first I would vote as YA, the second on should be Fantasy NA. Definitely not even close to erotica, though 😅 it’s pretty tame comparatively"I agree, it's tame, but I would still argue that the first is still NA. Smut, even tame smut, isn't usually found in YA these days
