Jesse’s Reviews > The Boats of the "Glen Carrig" and Other Nautical Adventures: The Collected Fiction of William Hope Hodgson, Volume 1 > Status Update

“The Adventure of the Claim Jumpers”

Originally I was convinced that the overtures to Lord Byron were an attempt to suggest Cargunka as having a similarly scandalous history. After this story and Hodgson doubling down, I think that we are meant to believe either that Cargunka IS an immortal Lord Byron, or he has a mania where he believes that he is.

“The Bells of the “Laughing Sally””

This is a Scooby Doo story with Cargunka as a Hodgson insert; he’s short, strong, a poet, and a great cook. The “is it a ghost?” plot calls to mind the author’s Carnacki stories. In this case, the MC is trying to salvage loot from an infamous wreck, and they twig to something weird when its bell sounds back their own time signal.

“The Adventure of the Headland”

Hodgson’s characterization of Captain Jat is considerably more miserable / less sympathetic in this adventure, with Pibby coming into his own amidst a neverending torrent of physical abuse sandwiched in between racist comments. The bizarre cannibal priests who run and hunt with the dogs came as quite a surprise and feel like a unique, weird horror.

“The Island of the Ud”

The stretch of Gault stories left me off-balance for this weird adventure where a Captain and his cabin-boy steal pearls from an island where Maenad-like woman who wear crab claws (…some of whom may HAVE crab claws…) and who worship a gargantuan sea creature. Shades of “The Shadow Over Innsmouth”, here.

“The Plans of the Reefing Bi-Plane”

So this is a thriller with anti-German-American sentiments and a bizarre amount of gun-toting bravado where the gentleman rogue refuses to shoot to kill but definitely shoots the shit out of a TON of German-American agents. If he wasn’t such a smug git about how he was only grazing them with his bullets then I could take it a bit more seriously.

“Trading With the Enemy”

Now we are full into World War I stories! Gault is blackmailed by Germans into providing fuel for German submarines at sea. It’s a pretty action-packed adventure once everything gets running and has a pretty good surprise twist to get our Captain out of almost certain death. I was thinking that Gault was going to sell the Germans out… but, well, that isn’t how things play out.

“My Lady’s Jewels”

This time the female foil is something of a love interest who tries to engage Gault for some smuggling before she decides that she’d rather run the jewels herself. This is disappointing for the Captain, naturally, as she declined to trust his gentleman smuggler’s honor, but he is not one to desert his lady in her hour of need.

“The Adventure of the Garter”

Another woman, another scam on ol’ Captain Gault. Having female characters is a good change-up for the stories… even if they are villains. They’re still in a battle of wits against the smuggler, but he is too Xanatos to get got by a lady and her garter. He does get a chance to tie this up with a slight bit of romantic intrigue, but what had happened.

“The Painted Lady”

Switching things up a bit with smuggling fine art—the Mona Lisa—as well as a female adversary for Captain Gault to joust with. I had the solution of this one figured out fairly well, but it may be because I have now spent to much time in the Captain’s general state of mind.

“The Problem of the Pearls”

Gault is all about the bluff. If the official he was teasing had smashed the eggs in a moment of frustration then he would not have been able to send such a smug letter revealing the nature of the deception. Idk, given how every story ends with some good-natured gloating, the schtick of these stories is starting to wear on me.